Link


Social

Embed


Download

Download
Download Transcript

[I. CHAIRMAN’S OPENING STATEMENT, FLAG SALUTE, ROLL CALL]

[00:00:11]

REGULARLY SCHEDULED PUBLIC WORK SESSION MEETING OF THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT OF THE TOWNSHIP OF MAHWAH. ADEQUATE NOTICE OF THIS MEETING HAD BEEN PROVIDED BY PUBLICATIONS IN THE RIDGEWOOD NEWS, AND THE RECORD COPIES OF THE AGENDA HAVE BEEN FORWARDED TO THE TOWNSHIP CLERK AND POSTED ON THE MUNICIPAL BUILDING BULLETIN BOARD. THIS MEETING IS ALSO BEING RECORDED AND STREAMED ON THE MAHWAH LIVE VIDEO PAGE. FLAG SALUTE. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS. ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. SO ROLL CALL, PLEASE. MR. ABSENT. MR. KASPARIAN. YES. MR. CARNEY, MISS. ABSENT. MR. LOCKWOOD HERE. MR. MOLFETTA HERE, MR. SERNA HERE, MR. SITAR. HERE, MR. TAYLOR, HERE. MR. CANOVA HERE. OKAY. THANK YOU. WE MOVE ON TO

[II. APPROVAL OF BILLS]

THE APPROVAL OF BILLS. WE HAVE ONE BILL FOR APPROVAL TONIGHT FOR SEPTEMBER 17TH, 2026 FOR A JOHN CONTE, ESQUIRE. DO I HAVE SOMEONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO MOVE THE BILL FOR APPROVAL? I'D LIKE TO MOVE THAT. OKAY. MR. LOCKWOOD, MR. TAYLOR, SECOND. ROLL CALL, MR. KASPARIAN. YES.

MR. LOCKWOOD. YES. MR. MOLFETTA. YES. MR. SERNA. YES. MR. SITAR. YES. MR. TAYLOR. YES. MR.

[III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: September 16, 2026]

CARNAUBA. YES. OKAY. THE BILL HAS BEEN APPROVED ON TO THE APPROVAL OF MINUTES. WE HAVE ONE SET OF MINUTES FROM SEPTEMBER 16TH, 2026, OUR LAST MEETING. ANY DISCUSSION GUYS.

THOUGHTS, COMMENTS, CONCERNS ON THE MINUTES AS HAVE BEEN PRESENTED. I READ THROUGH THEM.

THEY LOOK THEY LOOK GOOD. YEAH. THANK YOU, MR. LOCKWOOD. WOULD YOU LIKE TO MOVE THEM FOR APPROVAL? I'LL MOVE THEM. OKAY. DO I HAVE A SECOND? OKAY, MR. KASPARIAN SECOND. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ALL RIGHT. THE MINUTES HAVE BEEN APPROVED. ALL RIGHT. WE HAVE NO RESOLUTIONS FOR MEMORIALIZATION TONIGHT. SO I WILL OPEN UP THE MEETING TO THE PUBLIC FOR ANY QUESTIONS OF A GENERAL NATURE. NOT RELATED TO ANY DOCKETS THAT ARE ON THE AGENDA. OKAY, LET THE RECORD

[VI. PUBLIC HEARINGS]

SHOW THERE IS. THERE ARE NONE. NO ONE IS HERE TO SPEAK. SO BEFORE WE GO TO OUR FIRST DOCKET FOR THE NIGHT, I WOULD LIKE TO READ INTO THE RECORD THAT A DOCKET NUMBER 26-1621.

THE HIGHWAY DISPLAYS INC FROM ONE MOUNTAINSIDE AVENUE IN MAHWAH, NEW JERSEY. THIS HAS BEEN ADJOURNED TILL NOVEMBER 4TH. THEIR PLANNER COULD NOT BE IN ATTENDANCE AND THEY WERE GIVING TESTIMONY. SO THAT WILL BE MOVED AND NO FURTHER NOTICE SHALL BE GIVEN. SO WE MOVE TO OUR FIRST ACTUAL DOCKET THAT WILL BE HEARD FOR THE EVENING. AND THAT IS A DOCKET NUMBER 261626. A HINDU SAMAJ INC TWO. PLEASE COME FORWARD. MR. WHITAKER, HOW ARE YOU TONIGHT? VERY WELL. GOOD EVENING, MR. CHAIRMAN. MEMBERS OF THE BOARD. FOR THE RECORD, BRUCE WHITAKER FROM THE FIRM OF MCDONALD. WHITAKER, REPRESENTING HINDU SAMAJ IN CONNECTION WITH THE VARIANCE REQUEST BEFORE THIS BOARD. I'D LIKE TO GIVE A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE APPLICATION.

AND THEN I HAVE TWO WITNESSES TONIGHT TO PRESENT THE HINDU SAMAJ AS THE APPLICANT IS THE OWNER OF 247 WEST RAMAPO AVENUE, BLOCK 132, LOT NUMBER ONE IN THE R-40 ZONE IN THE TOWNSHIP OF MAHWAH. THE APPLICATION IS, FOR THE PURPOSES OF INSTALLING A SIX FOOT HIGH ALUMINUM ESTATE, OPEN FENCE, A SECURITY FENCE, IF YOU WILL, AROUND THE ENTIRE PROPERTY. NOW YOU KNOW THE PROPERTY. YOU'VE SEEN THE PROPERTY IT HOUSES THE TEMPLE AND THEIR COMMUNITY CENTER. A SIX FOOT FENCE IS A PERMITTED FENCE AND A REAR YARD AND A SIDE YARD. BUT THE LOCATION OF THIS PROPERTY, THERE ARE BASICALLY TWO FRONT YARDS. AND WE ARE SEEKING A SIX FOOT ESTATE STYLE FENCE FOR THOSE TWO FRONT YARDS. I USE THE WORD SECURITY BECAUSE THE PURPOSE BEHIND THE FENCE, AS YOU SEE IN THE APPLICATION I'VE MADE IN THE ADDENDUM ATTACHED TO THE APPLICATION, IS FOR SECURITY PURPOSES, THE ORDINANCE THAT WE ARE SEEKING THE VARIANCE FROM IS ORDINANCE 24-3.4, D THREE AND 24-5.661, WHICH BASICALLY DOES NOT PERMIT THE HEIGHT OF A FENCE FOR A FRONT YARD. IN COMING HERE TONIGHT, I WAS THINKING ABOUT THIS AND THINKING HOW TIMES HAVE CHANGED AND JUST THINKING ABOUT IT. I THINK ALL OF US SITTING HERE PROBABLY WENT TO SCHOOL AT A TIME. WE DIDN'T HAVE A SECURITY GUARD IN THE HIGH SCHOOL HALLS.

WE PROBABLY GOT TO SPORTING EVENTS OR SOMETHING ELSE WHERE WE DIDN'T HAVE TO GO THROUGH THE SECURITY THAT WE HAVE TODAY. AND I MYSELF ATTENDED CHURCH RIGHT NOW, AND ON A SUNDAY MORNING, THERE'S AN ARMED GUARD THERE BEFORE YOU WALK IN, AND IT'S A LITTLE BIT DISCONCERTING, BUT THOSE ARE THE TIMES, AND THAT'S WHAT WE HAVE HERE. THIS SECURITY FENCE, AS YOU SEE IN

[00:05:05]

THE ADDENDUM TO THE APPLICATION, HAS BEEN RECOMMENDED TO BE BUILT AND CONSTRUCTED BY HOMELAND SECURITY, AS WELL AS THE MAHWAH POLICE DEPARTMENT, BASED UPON INCIDENTS THAT OCCUR AT HOUSES OF WORSHIP AND IN PARTICULAR HOUSES OF WORSHIP, SUCH AS THE SAMAJ TEMPLE. AND SO FOR THAT PURPOSE, WE ARE REQUESTING THAT THE FENCE BE PERMITTED TO BE GRANTED A VARIANCE RELIEF FOR THE FRONT YARD SETBACKS NOW UNDER NJSA 40, COLUMN 55-2. YOUR PURPOSES BEHIND GRANTING VARIANCE RELIEF A AND B ARE VERY RELEVANT TO THIS. THEY BASICALLY STATE TO GUIDE THE DEVELOPMENT IN A MANNER TO PROMOTE PUBLIC HEALTH OR PUBLIC SAFETY. AND NUMBER TWO, TO SECURE SAFE SAFETY FROM PANIC OR MAN MADE DISASTERS. IN THE ADDENDUM THAT I PUT TO THIS APPLICATION, I ADDRESSED CONCERNS THAT YOUR ZONING OFFICER HAD AS IT PERTAINS TO THIS LOCATION OF THE FENCE. AND BEFORE THAT, I JUST WANT TO LET YOU KNOW THAT THIS TYPE OF SITUATION IS NOT CONFINED TO MAHWAH. IT'S SOMETHING THAT'S BEING DONE NATIONWIDE. AND THE REPORT ITSELF IS CONFIDENTIAL, BUT IT'S A REPORT THAT HOMELAND SECURITY, UNFORTUNATELY, IS DOING THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY, AND IT IS BASED UPON THE PROVISIONS OF THE NEW JERSEY DOMESTIC SECURITY PREPAREDNESS ACT. THE DOCUMENT ITSELF, AS I SAID, WAS PROMULGATED BY A STUDY DONE BY THE POLICE DEPARTMENT. THEY AUTHORED IT WITH HOMELAND SECURITY. THE REPORT PROVIDES A NUMBER OF SAFETY MEASURES THAT THEY SHOULD EMPLOY, AND THEY ARE IN THE PROCESS OF DOING. AND ONE OF THEM IS THIS SIX FOOT FENCE. THE. APPLICANT WOULD STIPULATE TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS I SET FORTH IN THE ADDENDUM. BUT I WANT TO PUT ON THE RECORD.

THE FENCE WILL BE SIX FEET IN HEIGHT IN THE FRONT YARD. IT WILL BE WITHIN THE ROAD WIDENING EASEMENT OF THE COUNTY OF BERGEN. THE COUNTY OF BERGEN PLANNING BOARD HAS ALREADY CONTACTED ME. THEY'RE IN THE PROCESS OF PREPARING A BASICALLY A LICENSE AGREEMENT.

THEY'RE USED TO THIS WITH OTHER FENCING AND OTHER IMPROVEMENTS IN THEIR RIGHT OF WAY, SO THAT THEY ARE GOING TO PERMIT THIS TO OCCUR. THE FENCE WILL BE WITHIN THE 50 FOOT WIDE SANITARY AND SEWER EASEMENT AREA, AND THE 15 FOOT WIDE SANITARY SEWER EASEMENT WITH THE TOWNSHIP OF MAHWAH. I HAVE BEEN IN CONTACT WITH THE TOWNSHIP ATTORNEY, AND I HAVE ALERTED THEM TO WHAT WE ARE LOOKING TO DO HERE. AND THE TOWNSHIP HAS LICENSE AGREEMENTS FOR THINGS LIKE THIS. AND SO ANY APPROVAL YOU WOULD BE GRANTING WOULD BE SUBJECT TO THAT. I WAS ADVISED BY MR. SOMERS OFFICE TODAY THAT THE LICENSE AGREEMENT IS BEING PREPARED TO BE PRESENTED TO THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL NEXT WEEK, WILL NOT BE SIGNED OFF UNTIL THERE'S AN ASSURANCE THAT WE HAVE VARIANCE RELIEF, BUT THEY'VE CONSENTED TO IT ALREADY.

THERE WAS A CONCERN IN HER REPORT ABOUT THE FENCING ON THE PLAN NOT BEING WITHIN THE SIGHT TRIANGLE, THE INTERSECTION. WE MODIFIED THE PLAN TO STIPULATE THAT IT WILL NOT BE. AND WE WOULD STIPULATE ALSO THAT AS THE FENCE IS BEING INSTALLED, IF AND IF YOU WERE TO APPROVE IT, THAT MR. KELLY HAS ANY CONCERN ABOUT IT ON A SITE VISITATION AND WHERE IT HAS TO ACTUALLY BE INSTALLED, WE OBVIOUSLY WOULD WORK WITH MR. KELLY IN REGARDS TO THIS. AND THEN FINALLY, THE CONCERN WAS THAT THIS FENCE IS GOING TO HAVE GATES AND THERE WILL BE A KNOX BOX, AND WE WILL INSTALL THAT, AND IT WILL BE SUBJECT TO THE POLICE DEPARTMENT, THE EMS REVIEW, FIRE DEPARTMENT REVIEW. AND THAT WOULD BE STANDARD ALSO. SO THAT'S AN OVERVIEW OF THE APPLICATION. AS I SAID, THE REPORT IS CONFIDENTIAL AND NOT TO GIVE IT OUT, BUT I DID. KEN READ JUST ONE OF THE CONCEPTS THAT'S PROMULGATED BY HOMELAND SECURITY, AND THAT IS FENCING MAY BE ERECTED TO IMPEDE PERSONAL ACCESS. ALSO, THIS IS WHAT KNOCKED ME OUT TO IMPEDE STAND OFF OF WEAPONS SYSTEMS SUCH AS ROCKET PROPELLED GRENADES, AND SERVE AS A BARRIER TO HAND THROWN WEAPONS. SO UNFORTUNATELY, THAT'S THE AGE WE'RE IN. AND IT COMES DOWN TO COMMUNITIES LIKE OURS THAT HAVE TO FACE THESE TYPE OF SITUATIONS. SO THAT'S THE OVERVIEW OF THE APPLICATION. I HAVE TWO WITNESSES THIS EVENING. I'M GOING TO HAVE DENISE DE SOLA SOLA, WHO IS A TRUSTEE AND WHO'S BEEN WITH THE TEMPLE SINCE ITS INCEPTION, WHEN THIS PLANNING BOARD IN THIS TOWN GRANTED ITS APPROVAL BACK IN 2000. AND THEN I HAVE DOUG

[00:10:04]

DOOLITTLE, AN ENGINEER WHO'S BEEN BEFORE YOU MANY TIMES FROM MCNALLY ENGINEERING, TO DESCRIBE THE ACTUAL SITE PLAN AND WHAT'S BEING DONE. SO UNLESS THERE'S ANY QUESTIONS OF ME, I WOULD HAVE OUR FIRST WITNESS SWORN IN. JUST ONE QUICK QUESTION BASED OFF OF WHAT YOU WERE JUST SAYING, MR. WHITAKER, THAT THE COUNTY AND THE TOWNSHIP APPROVAL, IT SEEMS LIKE YOU'VE ALREADY GOTTEN THAT BALL ROLLING AND THEY SEEM IN FAVOR OF IT. IS THAT WHAT I HEARD YOU SAY? ABSOLUTELY. THE CONCEPT IS THERE'S A FEDERAL GRANT FOR THIS TYPE OF PROTECTION. SURE. THERE'S TIMING FOR THOSE GRANTS. SO IN WE WERE WE WERE TOLD AND GOT THIS REPORT IN IN THE EARLY SPRING. AND BY THEN WE SET INTO MOTION REQUESTS WITH THE COUNTY EXPLAINING THE SITUATION TO THEM, EXPLAINING THE SITUATION TO THE TOWNSHIP MAYOR AND COUNCIL. AND THEY'RE BOTH IN THE PROCESS OF PREPARING THE DOCUMENT THAT'S NECESSARY FOR THIS TO BE INSTALLED ON THE LOCATION WE PROPOSE. OKAY, OKAY, OKAY. DID YOU HAVE A QUESTION? MR. NO, NO. OKAY. OKAY. MR. CHAIRMAN, I HAVE A QUESTION. YEAH. GO AHEAD. MR. DID HOMELAND SECURITY'S REPORT REQUEST A SIX FOOT HIGH FENCE? YES. AND THAT'S IN THE DOCUMENTATION THAT'S IN THE DOCUMENT I HAVE OPEN. IS IT BOTH OR JUST FOR THE RECORD? IS IT BOTH OR WHICH ONE REQUESTED IT. IT'S A JOINT REPORT. OKAY, OKAY. GO AHEAD, MR. SITAR. ON RICHARD'S QUESTION. SO IF THE TOWN'S APPROVING THIS AND THE COUNTY'S APPROVING THIS, WHY DO WE HAVE TO GO FIRST? THEY NEED THE VARIANCE FROM US. WE HAVE TO. OR THEY HAVE TO COME HERE BECAUSE OF THE HEIGHT. THE TOWN WANTS THE FENCE. OUR ORDINANCE ONLY PERMITS A FOUR FOOT HIGH FENCE. THEY'RE SEEKING A SIX FOOT HIGH FENCE. WHAT MR. WHITAKER IS DOING IS SETTING THE TABLE FOR WHY HIS TROOPS ARE GOING TO MEET, I BELIEVE, WHAT THE REQUIREMENTS ARE UNDER THE STATUTE. BUT YES, IT'S OUR JURISDICTION. AND HE HAS TO HAVE RELIEF FROM THIS BOARD.

YEAH. OKAY. BEFORE WE SAW THE FIRST WITNESS. AND I JUST WANT TO SAY, MADAM SECRETARY, NOTICE AND PUBLICATION ARE IN ORDER. THANK YOU. MR. MR. AND YOU HAVE TWO WITNESSES. GO AHEAD, PLEASE.

FIRST, TO EXPLAIN THE SITUATION SECURITY WISE AND JUST GIVE YOU A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF SOME OF THE INCIDENTS THAT HAVE ALREADY OCCURRED. AND THEN SECOND, JUST TO SHOW YOU THE NECESSITY FOR IT, IF IRREGARDLESS OF A REPORT THAT ALREADY SAYS IT SHOULD BE OKAY, THEN SECOND WOULD BE DUG A LITTLE TO GET INTO THE NUTS AND BOLTS OF THE PLAN ITSELF. SO THAT'S WHY HE'S AN ENGINEER.

HE'S OUR ENGINEER ENGINEERING. GREAT. LOVELY. THANK YOU. OKAY. YOUR FIRST WITNESS. PLEASE COME ON UP. HOW ARE YOU TONIGHT? ALL RIGHT. I'LL BE SWORN SAYING THAT IT'S MY BUDDY'S NAME. DID YOU RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND, SIR? DO YOU SOLEMNLY SWEAR OR AFFIRM THE TESTIMONY YOU GIVE IN THIS MATTER? BE THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH, AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH? YES. YOU CAN PUT YOUR HAND DOWN. STATE YOUR FULL NAME AND SPELL YOUR LAST NAME, PLEASE. FOR THE RECORD, DINESH KHOSLA, KHOSLA. THANK YOU, SIR. THANK YOU. I'D LIKE YOU TO TELL THE BOARD MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WHAT YOUR AFFILIATION IS WITH THE TEMPLE. I'M THE FOUNDER TRUSTEE OF THE TEMPLE. WE WERE TEN FAMILIES WHO STARTED THE TEMPLE, AND WE BECAME A CITIZEN OF MAHWAH AT THAT TIME. AND WE HAVE BEEN HERE SINCE 1994. AND I AM STILL. ON THE BOARD OF THE TEMPLE, MENTORING ALL THE YOUNGER PEOPLE SO THAT THE TEMPLE CAN CONTINUE TO RUN PAST MY LIFETIME. AND YOU'RE FAMILIAR WITH THE CORRECT TO SAY YOU'RE FAMILIAR WITH ALL THE ASPECTS OF THE TEMPLE AND THEIR ACTIVITIES. YES. AND YOU HAVE BEEN AN INTEGRAL PART OF OVERSEEING THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE ORIGINAL TEMPLE, AS WELL AS THE MORE RECENTLY APPROVED BY THE PLANNING BOARD. ADDITIONS AND MODIFICATIONS TO THE TEMPLE. YES, THAT WAS A VERY JOYOUS DAY, I MIGHT NOTE. I WENT BACK TO THE TEMPLE AND SAID, WHEN WE FIRST GOT OUR APPROVALS IN 1991, 1992, 93, WHICHEVER IT WAS, IT TOOK US ALMOST 27 MONTHS. WE DID NOT KNOW MUCH AND WE HAD TO LEARN. AND THIS LAST MEETING, IT TOOK 27 MINUTES FOR US TO GET THE APPROVALS. AND THERE WAS A LOT OF THUNDEROUS APPLAUSE IN THE TEMPLE THAT WE HAVE BECOME ONE WITH YOU. AND THAT MOST RECENT APPROVAL IS FOR MODIFICATIONS TO THE FRONT ENTRY, A REAR ADDITION AND SOME OUTDOOR AMENITIES, CORRECT? YES, YES. AND AM I CORRECT TO SAY THAT'S GOING TO BE STARTED IN THE SPRING, MARCH OR APRIL IS WHAT OUR TARGET DATE? OKAY. SO YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH THE REPORT FROM HOMELAND SECURITY AND THE POLICE DEPARTMENT? YES, IT'S A VERY EXTENSIVE REPORT, ALMOST 37 PAGES LONG, WITH VERY

[00:15:01]

SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS. AND THE RECOMMENDATIONS HAVE COME AFTER THEY REVIEWED ALL THE INCIDENTS, INSTANCES AND ALL THE INCIDENCES THAT HAPPENED AT OUR TEMPLE SINCE 1994. AND THE REPORT IN PART TALKS ABOUT THE MEMBERS, OR I SHOULD SAY, THE PARTICIPANTS AT THE TEMPLE, AND IT REFLECTS THAT THERE'S OVER 500 PEOPLE THAT ATTEND SERVICES AT VARIOUS TIMES, AND OVER 280 CHILDREN THAT GET EDUCATIONAL SERVICES THERE. THAT'S CORRECT. YES. THAT'S CORRECT. SO IT'S A VERY ACTIVE INSTITUTION. YES. SO AMONG THE THINGS THAT HAVE BEEN RECOMMENDED IS THIS SIX FOOT HIGH SECURITY FENCE. YES. THERE ARE OTHER RECOMMENDATIONS THAT WE DON'T NEED TO GET INTO AND GET TO DIVULGE OTHER THAN, SAY, THE OTHER RECOMMENDATIONS THAT THEY'RE MAKING FOR SECURITY PURPOSES DON'T NEED A VARIANCE, BUT THEY ARE BEING FOLLOWED BY THE TEMPLE. YES. SO WITH THAT SAID, JUST GIVE US AN THE BOARD, A SENSE OF THE OVERVIEW, IF YOU WILL, OF THE TYPE OF INCIDENCES THAT HAVE OCCURRED THROUGH THE YEARS. I, I, I GET VERY EMOTIONAL WHEN I THINK ABOUT WHAT HAS HAPPENED SINCE 1994, WHEN WE MOVED INTO THAT 200 YEAR OLD HISTORIC HOME AND CREATED A LITTLE SPACE FOR ALL OF US TO GET TOGETHER AND MEET SO THAT WE COULD PLAN ABOUT THE LARGER TEMPLE. THAT WAS IN 1994. EVEN THE DAY BEFORE WE INAUGURATED THE RENOVATED BUILDING, OUR ENTIRE PARKING LOT, WHICH WAS NOT A PAVED PARKING LOT, WAS RIPPED UP BY, BY, BY THOSE OFF ROAD VEHICLES AND EGGS WERE THROWN AND BEER BOTTLES WERE THROWN AND WINDOWS WERE BROKEN. WITH A LOT OF PAIN. THAT MORNING WE CLEANED UP AND MOVED IN AND DID OUR PRAYERS WITH 1020 FAMILIES THAT WERE THERE AND SOUGHT THE BLESSINGS OF OUR NEIGHBORS, OF OUR FRIENDS TO SAY WE WILL ONE DAY BUILD A LARGER TEMPLE TO MEET THE GROWING NEEDS OF OUR COMMUNITY. SEVERAL TIMES FROM 1994 TO 1995, THAT WAS REPEATED. THAT EXPERIENCE WAS REPEATED.

BOTTLES. BEER BOTTLES WERE REGULARLY THROWN, EGGS WERE REGULARLY THROWN AT THE TEMPLE.

AND ULTIMATELY. AND I WAS TRYING TO FIND IN MY OLD FILES. ULTIMATELY, MAHWAH POLICE AND FBI WERE ABLE TO BRING THAT SITUATION UNDER CONTROL. THE LAST INCIDENCE OF THAT WAS THAT OUR SIGNAGE WAS ALL STOLEN, AND IT WAS FOUND SOMEWHERE ABANDONED ON ROUTE 2 OR 2. IN 2007, WHICH IS THE MOST PAINFUL MEMORY. NOT THAT THE FIRST ONE WAS NOT. WE HAD BUILT A BEAUTIFUL TEMPLE. WE INAUGURATED THE TEMPLE ON SIXTH, SEVENTH, AND 8TH OF NOVEMBER.

ON 12TH OR 14TH OF DECEMBER. THAT NIGHT, WHEN THE PRIEST WAS LOCKING THE TEMPLE AND PUTTING THE ALARM, HE WAS ACCOSTED IN THE LOBBY OF THE ELEVATOR, WHICH OPENS AT THE GROUND LEVEL.

HE WAS ABUSED. HE WAS CURSED. HE WAS THREATENED BY TWO YOUNG MEN. ONE OF THEM HAD A 10 TO 12 INCH KNIFE IN HIS HAND, AND THEY WON. ONE HONDA WAS PARKED ON THE SITE. SOME OF OUR MEMBERS RIGHT AWAY INTERVENED WHEN WE HEARD FROM PRIEST'S WIFE WHAT WAS HAPPENING. WE CALLED THE POLICE AND THE POLICE WAS ABLE TO ARREST BOTH THESE YOUNG PEOPLE.

UNFORTUNATELY, THE MESSAGE SENT BY THE JUDICIARY WAS NOT A MESSAGE THAT WE LIKED OR ANYONE WOULD HAVE LIKED. IT IS THEIR FIRST OFFENSE AND THEY ARE NOT YET 18. THEY WERE ONE WAS 17 YEARS, NINE MONTHS, AND ONE WAS ABOUT 5 OR 10 DAYS BEFORE HE WAS 18. OVER $60,000 WORTH OF DAMAGE WAS DONE. THEY CAME WITH BASEBALL BATS WITH BRICKS. LOTS OF WINDOWS OF THE TEMPLE WERE BROKEN AND ALL THE EXTERIOR LIGHTS WERE BROKEN. WE STILL HAVE KEPT THREE BROKEN LIGHTS OUTSIDE, ONE ON THE LEFT HAND SIDE OF THE TEMPLE AND TWO ON THE FRONT. JUST AS A REMINDER THAT WE HAVE TO BE VIGILANT AND PEOPLE SAY, WHEN WOULD YOU CHANGE? I SAID, WHEN THE NEW CONSTRUCTION HAPPENS, IT WILL BE CHANGED AT THAT TIME. BUT WE WANT US TO BE VIGILANT AND BE CAREFUL ABOUT IT. THAT WAS A HUGE DAMAGE TO THE TEMPLE. ALMOST $60,000 IS WHAT WE SPENT IN REPAIRS. THE JUDGE UNFORTUNATELY TOLD US TO GO AND CLAIM FROM THE INSURANCE. IN 2019. APRIL 2019, OUR PRIEST WAS ACCOSTED BY A NEIGHBOR IN A PARKING LOT. NOT OUR PARKING LOT, BUT IN A SHOPPING CENTER PARKING LOT. AND HE WAS HIT, PUNCHED AND HIT. HE STOPPED THE

[00:20:06]

CAR ON A STOP SIGN. HE WAS PUNCHED AND HIT, AND HIS SIX YEAR OLD DAUGHTER WAS IN THE CAR, WAS TRAUMATIZED. AND THAT INDIVIDUAL IS OUR NEIGHBOR AND STILL LIVES, WE BELIEVE STILL LIVES IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD. HE WAS PROSECUTED. HE CALLED US AS DIRTY INDIANS. GO BACK TO YOUR COUNTRY AND ALL THE OTHER STUFF THAT ONE CAN IMAGINE. IN 2020 FOR FOR WOMEN, BEAUTIFULLY DRESSED, WITH A WITH A MAN CAME IN A LEXUS. THEY TRIED TO BREAK INTO THE TEMPLE. THEY WERE NOT ABLE TO BREAK INTO THE TEMPLE. THEY WENT TO THE PRIEST'S HOUSE, TRIED TO BREAK INTO THAT HOUSE.

PRIEST'S WIFE HAD JUST COME FROM INDIA. SHE DOESN'T SPEAK ENGLISH. SHE WAS. SHE PANICKED AND SHE. RATHER THAN CALLING THE POLICE, SHE CALLED ME AND I IMMEDIATELY CALLED THE POLICE.

BY THE TIME THE POLICE ARRIVED, THESE PEOPLE HAD LEFT. BUT WHAT THEY LEFT WAS THE MOST HORRIBLE AND MOST SHAMEFUL THING. THEY DEFECATED ON THE STEPS OF THE TEMPLE. THEY WERE EVENTUALLY ARRESTED IN MARYLAND. TO OUR RELIEF. TWO BEAUTIFUL STONE LIONS WERE STOLEN FROM OUR COMMUNITY CENTER. OUTSIDE OUR COMMUNITY CENTER, LIONS ARE CONSIDERED VERY SACRED, AND THEY WERE STOLEN AND THEY WERE VERY HEAVY, FOUR FOOT BY THREE FOOT STRUCTURES. AND IT HAPPENED SOMETIME IN THE NIGHT. AND THE CAMERAS, WE HAD CAMERAS THEY WERE NOT ABLE TO PICK AS TO WHO TOOK IT AND WHAT HAPPENED TO TO THEM. WHEN VIKRAM AND I HAVE A DUTY TO WALK, THE TEMPLE GROUNDS OFTEN, AND WHEN WE COME TO THE TEMPLE, WE OFTEN FIND THAT OUR PARKING LOT IS A PARTY SCENE IN THE NIGHT, SOMETIMES BY PEOPLE WHO JUST PULL IN. WE FIND LOTS OF BEER BOTTLES, LOTS OF HAMBURGER WRAPPERS, AND WE DON'T EAT BEEF. WE DON'T EAT MEAT. IT'S A VEGETARIAN CAMPUS. WE PICK THAT UP OFTEN. SO THIS FENCE AND THE GATE WOULD AT LEAST PREVENT THOSE THINGS FROM HAPPENING. BESIDES ALL THE OTHER BENEFITS THAT WE HAVE. SO THESE ARE THE SIX INCIDENCES THAT I TALKED ABOUT THE TEMPLE. TWO OF OUR MEMBERS OF OUR TEMPLE WERE HARASSED. I DON'T REMEMBER THE NAME OF THE STREET WHERE THEY LIVE, AND POLICE VERY KINDLY INTERVENED AND POSTED A, A POLICE CAR AROUND 3:00 EVERY TIME WHEN THEIR KIDS WERE COMING BACK FROM SCHOOL, THEIR NEIGHBORS TOLD THEM TO GET THE HELL OUT OF THAT. BOTH OF THEM.

ONE OF THEM IS A PHYSICIAN. ANOTHER ONE WORKS IN THE FINANCE INDUSTRY. THEY HAD TWO CHILDREN. LOTS OF OUR MEMBERS REPORT THAT THOSE THINGS HAPPEN. THEY HAVE REDUCED. BUT THE ATTACKS AGAINST THE TEMPLES NATIONALLY HAVE INCREASED TO AN EXTENT, WHICH IS HORRIFYING AND SHAMEFUL. I WILL JUST GIVE YOU WHAT HAS HAPPENED IN THE LAST 15 DAYS, LAST 15 DAYS, ON SEPTEMBER, IN SEPTEMBER, LATE SEPTEMBER, ONE OF OUR TEMPLES, NOT OUR TEMPLE, BUT ONE OF OUR HINDU TEMPLES IN JERSEY CITY WAS VANDALIZED AND ATTACKED. DOGS GO BACK HOME WAS THAT GRAFFITI WAS WRITTEN ALL OVER ON OCTOBER 3RD, SORRY. THEN ON SEPTEMBER 16TH IN LONG ISLAND, AND WE WERE TOLD THAT WE SHOULD BE VIGILANT AROUND THAT TIME, AND WE WEREN'T SURE WHY. SOME OF OUR MEMBERS WERE SAYING THAT. JUST BE CAREFUL. THEY MUST HAVE BEEN READING SOMETHING IN THE BOOKS. AND THEN WE FOUND OUT THAT THE TEMPLE IN LONG ISLAND, WHICH HAS A BEAUTIFUL STATUE OF MAHATMA GANDHI, THE APOSTLE OF PEACE AND NONVIOLENCE, THAT THAT GANDHI STATUE WAS DESTROYED. AND ANTI-HINDU GRAFFITI WAS WRITTEN ALL OVER THAT TEMPLE. AND THAT TEMPLE WAS ALSO VANDALIZED AND DAMAGED TO THEIR STRUCTURE WAS DONE ON OCTOBER 3RD IN OHIO, A HINDU TEMPLE WAS ATTACKED WITH BRICKS THROWN THROUGH THEIR WINDOWS, AND ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF HOSTILE ENVIRONMENT CREATED. IT IS. IT IS TRAGIC THAT PLACES OF WORSHIP COMMITTED TO PROMOTING ONENESS, HARMONY OF FAITH AMONG ALL HARMONY OF LOVE AND HARMONY AND LOVE AND FAITH AMONG

[00:25:07]

PEACEFUL. FOR PEACEFUL EXISTENCE AMONG PEOPLE ARE UNDER ATTACK. IT IS A SHAMEFUL THING. IT'S NOT A JOYOUS DAY TO COME AND SAY, WE ARE GOING TO SPEND $150,000 ON A FENCE, WHICH WILL PROTECT US TO SOME EXTENT. SO WE COME TO YOU WITH A REQUEST TO GIVE US YOUR BLESSINGS, SUBJECT TO WHAT OUR LAWYER, MR. WHITAKER, HAS ALREADY SUGGESTED. THANK YOU.

ANY QUESTIONS OF THE WITNESS? MR. COLESLAW, I AM VERY SORRY THAT YOU'VE HAD TO ENDURE ALL OF THAT. IT'S AWFUL. I HOPE YOU LIVE IN MAHWAH. I LIVE IN SADDLE RIVER. I HOPE THAT, BUT I'VE BEEN AFFILIATED WITH MAHWAH SINCE VALLEY REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER. YOU'RE A LOCAL GUY, AND I JUST. I HOPE THAT THOSE ACTIONS DON'T MAKE YOU FEEL THAT THAT IS. THE TOWNSHIP OF MAR WAS WAY BECAUSE IT IS NOT CERTAINLY NOT IN MY HOUSEHOLD AND CERTAINLY NOT THIS BOARD. AND I'M SORRY. IT'S AWFUL. THAT'S NO PLACE LIKE THAT IN COUNTRY LIKE AMERICA, IN MY OPINION. SO WE HAVE FOUND MALWARE TO BE A VERY WELCOMING COMMUNITY AND I, I HOPE SO, THANK YOU. OKAY. QUESTIONS FOR MR. KHOSLA FROM THE BOARD. MR. KASPARIAN, AGAIN, APOLOGIES FOR THE ONSLAUGHT OF OF INCIDENTS. ARE THERE ANY PLANS FOR A GUARD SHACK? GUARD SHACK? NOT AT THIS TIME. WE WE CAN'T AFFORD WE DON'T HAVE THE MONEY TO PAY FOR A GUARD. VIKRAM IS APPLYING FOR A GRANT. OKAY. GUARD FOR SPECIAL OCCASIONS. FEDERAL GOVERNMENT IS GIVING, I BELIEVE, 20,000 OR $25,000. GRANT. IF I UNDERSTOOD YOUR YOUR YOUR YOUR EXPLANATION OF THINGS, SOME OF THESE INCIDENTS HAD HAPPENED DURING TEMPLE HOURS OR WHEN WHEN TEMPLE PATRONS WERE ON SITE. IF THAT'S THE CASE, WILL YOUR GATES BE OPEN DURING TEMPLE HOURS, OR IS IT GOING TO BE A MANNED GATE WHERE YOU'LL HAVE CAR BY CAR ALLOWED IN AND OUT? THE GATE WOULD BE OPEN, BUT WE ARE GOING TO HAVE, WHAT ARE THE CAMERAS CALLED? DETECTING THESE BIG CAMERAS NOW.

AND THAT IS PART OF THE PROJECT. ONCE THE FENCING IS DONE, WE HAVE GIVEN THE. GIVEN THE NATURE OF THIS REPORT, THE NEW NEW JERSEY OFFICE OF HOMELAND SECURITY AND THE RECOMMENDATIONS FROM OUR POLICE HAS GIVEN US ANOTHER GRANT OF $175,000 TO HARDEN THE WINDOWS.

AUTOMATIC LOCKING OF THE DOORS. WITH A SWITCH OF A BUTTON, THE PRIEST CAN SHUT DOWN, SHUT DOWN A PRIEST OR THE MANAGER CAN SHUT DOWN VARIOUS PARTS OF THE BUILDING DEPENDING ON THE THREAT. SO THEY HAVE VIEWED THE THREAT TO BE VERY IN A VERY SERIOUS WAY. SO WE ARE IMPROVISING. WE HOPE WE DIDN'T HAVE TO DO IT, BUT WE LEARNED ABOUT THIS GRANT OF $25,000 A YEAR FOR SPECIAL OCCASIONS. YES. AND WE ALWAYS CALL POLICE WHEN WE ARE EXPECTING A LARGE NUMBER OF PEOPLE. AND THEY HAVE BEEN VERY, VERY HELPFUL. HAS THERE ANY THOUGHT GONE INTO OR SITE ANALYSIS AS FAR AS HAVING AN ARMED GUARD ON SITE? YEAH, IT IT JUST DOESN'T FIT WITH OUR CULTURE AND OUR ETHOS. AND WE HAVE VOLUNTEERS. WE HAVE 7 OR 8 VOLUNTEERS ON SUNDAY WHO ARE CONSTANTLY ON THE LOOKOUT FOR ANY SUSPICIOUS ACTIVITY, BECAUSE WE HAVE CHILDREN IN CLASSES. SURE. AND WE HAVE MEMBERS, ADULTS WHO ARE THERE. OKAY. I'M NOT SURE IF YOU'LL BE ABLE TO ANSWER THIS QUESTION. DO DO YOU DO YOU KNOW WHAT THE CHARACTERISTICS OF THE FENCE ARE LIKE? IS IT CONSIDERED A NON SCALING FENCE? I'M NOT SURE IF THAT'S MORE FOR THE ENGINEER FOR THE ENGINEER. BUT THEY DID. THEY DID TELL YOU WHAT IT IS. IT SHOWS YOU IT'S THOSE IT'S A VERTICAL ALUMINUM. I SEE THE BLACK AND WHITE ON THE SITE PLAN. I WAS JUST WONDERING IF IT'S CLASSIFIED A CERTAIN TYPE. YEAH IT'LL IT'LL BE CLASSIFIED AND DONE. THE TEMPLE IS VERY FORTUNATE. MR. KAHANA, WHO'S SITTING HERE THIS EVENING, ALSO, HE HAPPENS TO BE THE HEAD OF SECURITY FOR ALL GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES IN NEW YORK CITY. AND HE'S WITH AFFILIATED WITH THE TEMPLE. SO HE'S OBVIOUSLY AN ADVISOR FOR THIS. AND WE'RE VERY FORTUNATE TO HAVE HIM HERE.

OKAY. OKAY. AND ONE LAST QUESTION, PLEASE. YEAH. GO AHEAD. IN THE. MR. WHITAKER, AS YOU MAY KNOW, THE ANSWER IS THE THE REPORT IS DEFINITELY REQUESTING A SIX FOOT OR SUGGESTING A SIX FOOT HIGH FENCE, SUGGESTING A SIX FOOT HIGH FENCE WITH A FENCE OF ANY HEIGHT WOULD DO ANY GOOD. SIX FOOT OR NOTHING. IS THAT WHAT THE REPORT'S KIND OF SAYING?

[00:30:01]

YES. OKAY. AND NO OTHER QUESTIONS. THERE'S A CONDITION OF THE GRANT ALSO. YES. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FOR. MR. YEAH. GO AHEAD. AGAIN, TERRIBLY SORRY TO HEAR ABOUT YOUR SITUATION.

IS THERE AN EXISTING FENCE TODAY OR IS THIS AN ALL BRAND NEW FENCE? OKAY. THANK YOU.

OKAY. ANYONE ELSE DOWN HERE, MR. MOLFETTA? THERE'S I KNOW THERE IS SOME SCREENING FROM THE ROAD. YOU KNOW, MY CONCERN IS JUST THE VISUAL APPEARANCE OF IT. BECAUSE YOU DON'T WANT IT TO FEEL LIKE A LIKE A JAIL. RIGHT. BUT WHEN YOU'RE WHEN YOU WHEN I THINK ABOUT WHAT THEY DID AT THE STOCK EXCHANGE BUILDING, IT'S ACTUALLY A BEAUTIFUL FENCE. THERE'S SOME LANDSCAPE THAT HELPS KIND OF ALLOW IT TO BLEND INTO THE LANDSCAPE. CURRENTLY, I LOOKED, I WANTED TO SEE THE AERIAL JUST TO GET A FEELING. I MEAN, MY FRIENDS ARE MEMBERS OF THIS TEMPLE, SO I KNOW IT, BUT IS THERE AN ADDITIONAL PLAN FOR PLANTINGS? YES YOU DO. YES, WE CAN GO OVER IT WITH DOUG DOOLITTLE, BUT THE REPORT REQUIRES THAT THE PLANTINGS SUGGEST THAT THE PLANTINGS BE INSIDE THE FENCE, BECAUSE THE FENCE HAS TO BE OPEN SO THAT PEOPLE CAN BE SEEN. THEY DON'T WANT PEOPLE HIDING BEHIND. THAT MAKES SENSE ON THE STREET SIDE.

SURE. SO IT'LL BE THE FENCE AND THERE'LL BE LANDSCAPING BEHIND IT. AND THE FENCE IS VERY TYPICAL TYPE OF FENCE. IT'S, YOU KNOW, THIS IS NOT A STOCKADE FENCE, A WOODEN FENCE.

NO, IT'S A PRETTY FENCE. WE'RE SEEING IT HERE. WE SEE IT. GOOD, MR. MOLFETTA. ALL RIGHT. GOOD.

COMING DOWN THIS WAY. I DON'T HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, MR. CAMILLA, ARE YOU GOOD? OKAY. EXPERTS? NO, I HAVE NO QUESTIONS. I THINK MY QUESTIONS ARE FOR THE ENGINEER, SO NO QUESTIONS. OKAY. THANK YOU, MR. MAYOR. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WHEN DOES THE PUBLIC GET TO ASK QUESTIONS? OH, RIGHT.

YEAH. PUBLIC. YEAH. COME UP. THIS IS A TIME FOR QUESTIONS FOR MR. KOSHLAND, NOT TESTIMONY.

NO NO NO NO QUESTIONS. QUESTIONS. GREAT. SO IF YOU COULD JUST COME IN AND STATE YOUR NAME AND YOUR ADDRESS FOR THE RECORD, PLEASE. 219 I SHARED 250FT OF PROPERTY LINE TO THE TEMPLE. OKAY, SO I'M JUST QUESTIONS OF LIKE WHAT TYPE OF FENCE IT'S GOING TO BE.

AND THERE'S ALSO A FIRE ACCESS ROAD ON THAT. SO IS THAT GOING TO BE BLOCKED OR I'M ALSO A FIREMAN FOR 30 YEARS FOR THE TOWN. SO I'M JUST TRYING TO HAVE THE ENGINEER. YEAH. I WAS GONNA SAY THAT'S FOR THE ENGINEER. IF YOU WANT TO SEE THE FENCE, YOU CAN COME ON UP HERE AND THERE IS A GATE TO CLARK. IT'S BASICALLY WITH A WITH A BOX. THERE'S A GATE TO CLARK WITH A BOX ON THEIR DRAWING FOR FIREFIGHTERS AND POLICE. SO IT'S NOT A VERY VISIBLE LIKE, YOU KNOW, IMPEDING FENCE. IS IT GOING TO BE GOING. THANK YOU. YEAH. NO PROBLEM. BEFORE OR AFTER THE SIEGE THAT WE PUT UP. THE TREES ARE SUPPOSED TO BE INSIDE THE FENCE. OKAY. BECAUSE I HAVE A FENCE TO ON HALF MY PROPERTY BETWEEN OURS. SO I'M JUST WONDERING IS GOING TO GO RIGHT AGAINST MINE WITH NO TREES OR. YEAH. SO WE'RE GOING TO HAVE THE ENGINEER GIVE TESTIMONY. AND THEN IF THE QUESTIONS NOT ANSWERED, YOU COME BACK UP, YOU CAN ASK HIM QUESTIONS. AND THEN YOU CAN ALSO GIVE TESTIMONY WHEN EVERYONE'S DONE OF YOUR OWN, IF YOU IF YOU WISH. YEAH. OF COURSE THAT'S CORRECT. YOU KNOW, NO WORRIES, NO WORRIES.

OKAY. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FOR MR. KOZEL? I CAN'T SEE BEHIND. THERE'S NO ONE SITTING HERE.

RIGHT. WE'RE GOOD. OKAY. ALL RIGHT, MR. WHITAKER, YOUR NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU, THANK YOU.

YOU RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. PLEASE, MR. DOOLITTLE, SOLEMNLY SWEAR OR AFFIRM THE TESTIMONY GIVEN THIS MATTER. BE THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH, NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH, I DO THANK YOU.

STATE YOUR FULL NAME. YOUR LAST NAME? DOUGLAS W DOOLITTLE, DOOLITTLE. BUSINESS ADDRESS 169 RAMAPO VALLEY ROAD, OAKLAND, NEW JERSEY. MR. DOOLITTLE, JUST GIVE THE MEMBERS OF THE BOARD THE BENEFIT OF YOUR EDUCATION AND PROFESSIONAL BACKGROUND. I KNOW YOU'VE BEEN HERE BEFORE, BUT JUST PUT IT ON THE RECORD. YEAH, I HAVE A DEGREE FROM NJIT IN CIVIL ENGINEERING. GRADUATED IN 79. I'VE BEEN A LICENSED ENGINEER, LAND SURVEYOR AND PLANNER IN NEW JERSEY SINCE THE MID 80S. I'VE LIVED AND GREW UP IN ALLENDALE. I'VE LIVED IN MORWELL FOR ABOUT 35 YEARS, AND I'VE DONE NUMEROUS TESTIMONY ON APPLICATIONS SUCH AS THIS IN FRONT OF ZONING, PLANNING BOARDS, ETC. MR. DOOLITTLE, THIS BOARD STILL RECOGNIZES YOU AS AN EXPERT IN ENGINEERING.

THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MR. DOOLITTLE. YOU'VE BEEN ENGAGED BY THE APPLICANT FOR THE PURPOSES OF CREATING THIS SITE. PLAN FOR THE INSTALLATION OF A FENCE. IS THAT CORRECT? YES.

AND YOU'VE ALSO BEEN INVOLVED WITH THE PREVIOUS SITE PLANS, INCLUDING THE ONE MORE RECENTLY APPROVED FOR THE ADDITIONS TO THE BUILDING ITSELF AND FOR THE OUTDOOR AMENITIES, CORRECT? YES.

AND YOU'VE BEEN TO THE SITE, OBVIOUSLY, AND FAMILIAR WITH ALL ASPECTS OF THE SITE. YES.

SO WHAT I'D LIKE YOU TO DO IS WALK THE BOARD THROUGH WHAT IS BEING PROPOSED FOR THE FENCING AND WHERE THE ESTATE FENCING IS BEING INSTALLED. THE CHAIN LINK FENCING IS GOING TO BE INSTALLED AND TAKE US THROUGH THAT. YEAH. IF I COULD JUST WALK OVER TO THE PICTURE, IT

[00:35:02]

MIGHT BE A LITTLE EASIER. YEAH. JUST GRAB THAT MICROPHONE. YEAH, THE HANDHELD RIGHT BEHIND YOU, BEHIND YOU, BEHIND YOU. YEP. YOU GOTTA HIT THE GREEN BUTTON. HOLD IT DOWN. SO WHAT'S DEPICTED UP THERE ON JUST A BUTTON ON THE EASEL, IS IT? YEAH. HOLD IT, HOLD IT. THERE YOU GO FIRST AND THEN IT'LL GO GREEN. IT'S NOT A GREEN. HELLO? YEAH. YOU'RE GOOD. SO WHAT'S DEPICTED ON THE EASEL IS A COPY OF THE PLAN THAT WAS SUBMITTED WITH THE APPLICATION. OKAY. IS THAT CORRECT? YES. AND THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON VALLEY ROAD. IT'S ON THE EAST SIDE OF RAMAPO VALLEY ROAD. IT'S ON THE NORTH SIDE OF WEST RAMAPO AVE. IT'S A CORNER LOT. AND THE REASON WHY WE'RE HERE FOR VARIANCES TONIGHT IS BECAUSE WE HAVE TWO STREET FRONTAGES THAT WERE NOT ALLOWED TO BE HIGHER THAN FOUR FEET WITH OUR FENCE, THE SIDE PROPERTY LINES, WE'RE ALLOWED TO HAVE SIX FEET. WE'RE NOT HERE. THAT'S NOT A VARIANCE ISSUE TODAY. WE'RE BASICALLY PUTTING THE FENCE ALONG THE PROPERTY LINE AROUND THE INTERIOR SIDE AND REAR LINES.

WE'RE PUTTING IT ALONG THE FRONT STREET LINE, BASICALLY EITHER ALONG OR SLIGHTLY OVER THE COUNTY ROAD WIDENING EASEMENT. AND THEN THE SAME THING OUT AROUND 202 AROUND PO VALLEY ROAD. WE PUT THE REQUIRED SITE DISTANCES IN BASED ON COUNTY REQUIREMENTS FOR BOTH VERTICAL AND HORIZONTAL SITE DISTANCES. I BELIEVE WE HAVE 403 REQUIRED FOR THE RIGHT TURN OUT OF THE TEMPLE, AND WE HAVE 500 REQUIRED FOR THE TURN OUT OF WEST RAMAPO AVE. THE FENCING AT THE REAR WHERE THE NEIGHBOR WAS CONCERNED. THIS WILL HAVE A GATE THAT'S A LITTLE BIT MORE PERMANENT THAN THE ONE THAT'S THERE. NOW. IT'S KIND OF OLD AND RUNDOWN, AND I DON'T THINK IT'S EVEN LOCKED. THIS WILL HAVE A KNOCK BOX ON IT FOR THE FIRE DEPARTMENT, THE EMS AND THE AMBULANCE TO GET THROUGH IF NEED BE REQUIRED. THIS ACTUALLY WAS A 50 FOOT WIDE RIGHT OF WAY HERE AT ONE TIME THAT WAS VACATED. THAT'S WHY THIS HAS A LOT OF UTILITIES IN IT, ALONG WITH THE SANITARY SEWER, WHICH IS WHY WE'RE REQUESTING A A WAIVER OR A VARIANCE FROM THE BOARD TO PUT THIS FENCE IN THAT RIGHT OF WAY. IF YOU DON'T MIND, IDENTIFY WHAT SIDE WHEN YOU SAY ALONG THIS LINE, JUST IDENTIFY WHICH LINES YOU'RE TESTIFYING.

THE THE NORTHERLY PROPERTY LINE. YES. WE'RE PUTTING THE FENCE ALONG THE RIGHT OF WAY LINE OUT ON WEST RAMAPO AVE. WE HAVE AN ISSUE WHERE THERE'S A WATER LINE HERE THAT'S BACK INSIDE OF ON OUR PROPERTY. THERE IS NO EASEMENT FOR IT CURRENTLY, NOW, OR IN THE PROCESS OF GETTING AN AGREEMENT, AS MR. WHITAKER MENTIONED, TO HAVE THAT ACCESS FOR THE TOWN TO GET IN THERE AND SERVICE THAT AS MAY BE REQUIRED AND ANYTHING THAT NEEDS TO BE RESTORED WOULD BE AT OUR CLIENT'S EXPENSE. THE PRIMARY ACCESS FOR THE SITE IS OUT ON 202 RAMAPO VALLEY ROAD.

THIS WILL ALSO HAVE THE GATES WITH THE KNOCK BOX. THIS WILL BE 99.9% OF YOUR ACCESS OFF THE COUNTY ROAD. THE ONE IN THE BACK AGAIN WILL GENERALLY BE LOCKED 99.9% OF THE TIME, BUT IT WILL BE ACCESSIBLE WITH A KNOCK BOX. THE FENCE ITSELF IS A TYPICAL SIX FOOT HIGH FENCE.

IT'S ALUMINUM THREE QUARTER INCH SQUARE BARS SPACED ABOUT THREE AND A HALF TO FOUR INCHES APART, SO THE VOIDS THROUGH THE FENCE ARE ALMOST 90%, WHERE A LOT OF TOWNS REQUIRE 50% FENCE, 50% OPEN. THIS IS ABOUT 90% OPEN. LIKE I SAID, SIX FOOT HIGH ALUMINUM BLACK. IT BLENDS IN AND IT DOES LOOK LIKE MORE OF YOUR UPSCALE FENCING YOU SEE ON SOME OF THE BIGGER STATES, SAY IN RIO VISTA OR OTHER TOWNS SUCH AS THAT. SO IT IS KIND OF BLENDING IN WITH WHAT'S HERE, BECAUSE THIS PROPERTY IS PRETTY MUCH SURROUNDED WITH ARBORVITAE OR PINES OR WHATNOT. I HAD A QUITE LENGTHY CONVERSATION WITH MISS DE NOCHE AND WHATEVER PINES ARE HERE THAT HAVE TO BE TAKEN DOWN, WHETHER THEY'RE DEAD OR THEY'RE IN THE WAY, THEY WILL BE REPLACED WITH FIVE FOOT ARBORVITAE, THE GIANTS THAT ARE DEER RESISTANT AS WELL, AND WE'RE WILLING TO WORK WITH THAT. WITH MIKE, YOUR BOARD ENGINEER, AS TO WHERE WE PUT THEM AND HOW WE SPACE THEM, THEY WILL BE PUT ON THE INSIDE. AND THAT AGAIN, IS FOR TWO REASONS. ONE, FOR ESTHETICS.

ALSO, WE DON'T WANT TO GROW ANY UP. SO BECOME A PLACE FOR PEOPLE TO HIDE IN THEM BEFORE THEY GO INTO THE PROPERTY, OR USE THEM AS A LADDER TO GET OVER THE FENCE. SO THAT'S PRETTY MUCH THE APPLICATION AND FENCING TO THE REAR AS A FENCE THAT IS PERMITTED BY THE ORDINANCE TO BE SIX FEET IN HEIGHT. YES THAT'S CORRECT. EXCUSE ME. THAT FENCE, JUST SO THE RECORD IS CLEAR, WILL BE A CHAIN LINK FENCE. YES, YES, THAT'S THE ONE THAT'S ALONG CLARK. LIKE THAT ACCESS IS BY THAT CLARK AVENUE. IT'S SEPARATE. RIGHT. IT SEPARATES THE PROPERTY BEHIND US ON CLARK AND OUR PROPERTY. IT'S A SMALL SECTION. OKAY. NOTHING FURTHER.

OKAY. WAS JUST MY OWN EDIFICATION. NO WAY TO KEEP THIS OUT OF THE EASEMENT. I'M NOT, LIKE, SUPER FAMILIAR WITH, LIKE, EVERY PART OF THE PROPERTY. I DRIVE PAST IT ALL THE TIME, BUT THERE WAS NO WAY TO KEEP THESE THINGS OUT OF THE EASEMENT. THIS IS PRIMARILY THE

[00:40:04]

MAIN ACCESS HERE AND THE PARKING UP AGAINST THE PROPERTY LINE. WE WOULD LOSE SUBSTANTIAL PARKING IF WE HAD TO PULL IT IN. IT'S ABOUT TWO FEET BEHIND THE CURB NOW. WE ACTUALLY TRIED TO NEGOTIATE WITH THE HOTEL NEXT DOOR, WHERE WE WOULD MOVE IT TO THE MIDDLE OF THEIR CURB LINE AND OUR CURB LINE, BUT THEY WEREN'T INTERESTED, SO WE KEPT IT JUST TWO FEET IN. SO WHEN CARS NOSE IN, THEY WON'T RUN INTO IT. BUT OTHER THAN THAT, WE WOULD LOSE SUBSTANTIAL PARKING ALONG THAT PROPERTY LINE. OKAY, PARKING IS REQUIRED. IT'S NEEDED. YEAH. NO, IT MAKES SENSE. WE ACTUALLY GOOD PARKING ALREADY WHEN THEY ORIGINALLY GOT APPROVALS. THAT'S CORRECT.

OKAY. AND THEN THE WATER YOU WERE MENTIONING THE EASEMENT FOR THE WATER. CAN YOU JUST ELABORATE ON THAT A LITTLE BIT MORE. SO YEAH. TELL US WHERE THE FENCE IS GOING TO BE AND HOW IT WILL BE ACCESSED AND HOW THAT WILL ALL WORK. MAHWAH HAS A WATER LINE IN ON OUR PROPERTY, OF WHICH WE DID NOT KNOW AT THE TIME. IT'S ABOUT 1015FT IN ON OUR PROPERTY. IT RUNS ALL THE WAY TO THE NORTH EAST END OF OUR PROPERTY ALONG WEST VALLEY ROAD. WE'RE PUTTING OUR FENCE OUT ALONG THE COUNTY WIDENING EASEMENT, WHERE WE ACTUALLY GO INTO IT A LITTLE BIT DOWN HERE, AND WE AGREED TO DO AN AGREEMENT WITH THEM BECAUSE THAT'S NOT ACCESSED VERY OFTEN.

THERE IS A HYDRANT ON IT OVER HERE. I BELIEVE WE HAVE A WATER SERVICE TO OUR HOUSE, RECTORY AND OR TO THE CHURCH. RIGHT. THAT BORDERLINE, I'M GOING TO SAY, HAS PROBABLY BEEN THERE SINCE THE 80S. IT'S PROBABLY A DUCTILE IRON PIPE, AND THE MAINTENANCE ON IT IS LITTLE TO NONE. IF THEY NEED TO GET IN THERE AND DIG IT UP, IF THERE IS A BROKEN PIPE OR AN EXPANSION OR ANYTHING TO BE DONE, THEY WILL HAVE A DOCUMENT FROM US GIVING THEM PERMISSION TO DO WHATEVER THEY NEED TO DO TO GET IN THERE AND DO THAT, WHETHER IT'S TAKING EVERGREENS DOWN, WHETHER IT'S REMOVING PORTIONS OF THE FENCE, AND THAT ALL HAS TO BE PUT BACK AT OUR CLIENT'S EXPENSE. THAT'S THE AGREEMENT WITH THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL. YEP. UNDERSTOOD. AND I GUESS THERE'S NO WAY TO PUT THE FENCE. WE CAN'T BECAUSE WE'VE GOT A WETLANDS LIMIT HERE. AND THAT WOULD PUT IT ABOUT 12FT INTO THAT WETLANDS, WHICH THE DEP IS NO WAY GOING TO LET US PUT A FENCE IN THE WETLANDS. THEY DON'T EVEN LIKE TEMPORARY FENCES. RIGHT. SO THAT PART OF THIS IS THERE'S MANY WATER LINES. I THINK MR. KELLY WOULD CONCUR, THAT HAVE BEEN INSTALLED OVER THE MANY YEARS WITHOUT SUFFICIENT DEED OR EASEMENTS AND THINGS LIKE THAT.

THAT'S ALL GOING TO GET ESTABLISHED WITH THIS DOCUMENT. OKAY. THANK YOU, MR. DOOLITTLE.

ALL RIGHT. QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD? GO AHEAD, MR. KASPARIAN. SIR, CAN YOU TELL ME, IS THIS CONSIDERED A NONSCALING FENCE? YES, I BELIEVE IT IS BASED ON THE DIAGRAM OF THE SIX FOOT SECURITY FENCE. AND THE TYPICAL RAIL THAT IT'S SHOWING HERE. I CAN'T IMAGINE THAT THIS IS ANY MORE BEEFED UP THAN THE FENCE I HAVE AROUND MY YARD. BEEFED UP AS FAR AS WHAT BEING ABLE TO HANG ON IT AND CLIMB OVER IT. IT CERTAINLY IS STRUCTURAL ENOUGH THAT YOU COULD DO THAT IF YOU WERE ABLE TO. THAT'S THE WHOLE IDEA OF KEEPING IT VISIBLE FROM THE STREET. OKAY.

CAN YOU CAN YOU TELL ME HOW MANY POUNDS OF FORCE THE FENCE CAN HANDLE? NO, I DON'T KNOW.

THAT WILL BE DEALT WITH AT THE TIME OF PERMITTING WITH THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT. OKAY, SO WE DON'T KNOW HOW, HOW, HOW THIS IS REALLY GOING TO LOOK, THAT IT'S NOT GOING TO MAKE YOU LOOK LIKE A JAIL OR SOMETHING THAT WAS MENTIONED EARLIER. DO YOU HAVE ANY INTENTIONS WHEN YOU DO THE LANDSCAPING OF PLANTING, SINCE YOU WANT TO BE ON THE INSIDE OF THIS, APPARENTLY ABOUT PLANTING RIGHT UP AGAINST THE FENCE? YES, WE CAN DO THAT. YES. SO IT CAN HELP MASK THIS. YES. THAT'S THE WHOLE INTENTION OF THE FIVE FOOT HIGH ARBORVITAE. WE WERE GOING TO GO TO FOUR, WE WERE GOING TO GO TO SIX. THEY SAID, LET'S GO TO FIVE BECAUSE THE FIRST THREE YEARS IT'S GENERALLY STUNNED TO GROW. AND THEN AFTER THAT IT'S RIGHT UP TO THE TOP AND UP TO THE ROOF. SO WE DIDN'T WANT TO GO OVER TO ARGUE THE FACT THAT THEY GROW BECAUSE MINE I'VE BEEN TOPPING FOR YEARS. YES. SO. OKAY. NOT TOO CLOSE THOUGH. I THINK THAT'S IT, MR. CHAIRMAN. THANK YOU. OKAY. THANK YOU, THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE DOWN HERE? MR. MR. ARE YOU GOOD SO FAR? OKAY. COMING DOWN THIS WAY. SO JUST A QUESTION THAT OFFENDS THEM. THE CHAIN LINK FENCE IN THE BACK AND THE NORTHERLY SIDE, THAT'S GOING TO BE A SIX FOOT CHAIN LINK PERMITTED BY ORDINANCE. YES. AND IT'S JUST A CLEAR NO NO SIDES, NO SIGNS. OKAY. GOOD.

CAN I HAVE A COUPLE QUESTIONS? OKAY, MR. LOCKWOOD, I'LL COME TO YOU NEXT. YEP. OKAY. FIRST QUESTION IS JUST ABOUT THE KNOCK BOX, JUST THE LOCATION OF THE KNOCK BOX. SO IT'S IN THE BACK CORNER. I GUESS IT'S BY CLARK AVENUE. YES. SO CLARK AVENUE. SO ON THIS MAP, CLARK IS CLARK AVENUE RAILROAD. IT WAS A PAPER STREET THROUGH OUR PROPERTY AT ONE TIME AND IT WAS VACATED. I DON'T REMEMBER WHEN, BUT THAT'S WHY ALL THE UTILITIES RUN THROUGH THERE. SO IN VACATING THAT, THEY TOOK EASEMENTS BACK FOR THE UTILITIES. OKAY. SO MY QUESTION IS WHY IS THE KNOCK BOX IN THAT BACK CORNER AS OPPOSED TO BECAUSE THE KNOCK BOX IS USED FOR THE FIRE DEPARTMENT? YES. RIGHT. IT'S ON BOTH. IT'S ON BOTH. WE HAVE ONE OUT AT ROUTE 202. OKAY. AND WE ALSO HAVE THAT ONE AS A BACKUP ACCESS. SHOULD THERE BE AN ACCIDENT OR

[00:45:02]

SOMETHING IN FRONT OF THE ONE OVER HERE, THEY CAN GET IN THROUGH THE BACK ONE. OKAY.

OKAY. SO THAT'S MY FIRST QUESTION. SECOND QUESTION IS, AND I THINK YOU REFERENCED THIS, IF I'M I WANT TO KIND OF ORIENT, I GOT MY PAPER THE OTHER WAY AROUND, BUT ON THE SOUTHWEST SIDE, WHICH IS WEST RAMAPO AVENUE, YOU SAID THAT THERE WERE TREES THAT IF THEY HAD TO BE TAKEN OUT, THEY WOULD BE REMOVED. YEP. RIGHT. SO MY I HAVE MY QUESTION IS I WENT TO THE PROPERTY AND WHEN ALONG THAT ROAD, I GUESS ABOVE THIS WETLANDS, IT'S QUITE STEEP HILL.

RIGHT. AND THEN THERE'S NOT. AND I JUST WANT YOUR OPINION BECAUSE IN MY VIEW, IT DIDN'T SEEM LIKE THERE WAS A LOT OF ROOM TO ACTUALLY ENGINEER AND PUT A FENCE IN THERE. IN ADDITION, THERE'S A GUARDRAIL THAT GOES ALONG PART OF THE ROAD THERE. YEAH, THE GUARDRAILS FURTHER OUT. IF YOU LOOK ON THE MAP, YOU CAN SEE IT, RIGHT? OH, OKAY. SO MY QUESTION WAS THE GUARDRAIL. THERE'S THE GUARDRAIL. THIS IS A GUARDRAIL HERE. OH, I GOT TO OPEN THAT UP.

MY QUESTION REALLY IS, AND I'M GOING TO HAVE THE SAME QUESTION ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE PROPERTY, WHICH IS JUST AS A LAYPERSON GOING BY AND LOOKING AT THE PROPERTY, IT JUST SEEMED TO ME THAT IT WAS GOING TO BE AWFULLY DIFFICULT TO GET A FENCE INTO THAT WITH THE THE HILL, THE PROXIMITY TO THE ROAD. SO I JUST ASKING FOR YOUR ENGINEERING OPINION OF THE FEASIBILITY TO ACTUALLY DO THIS ON THAT SIDE. AND THAT'S A GOOD POINT BECAUSE THE HILL FOR THE WETLANDS IS MUCH STEEPER AS YOU GET FARTHER NORTH INTO THE PROPERTY. SO KEEPING IT OUT CLOSER TO WEST RAMAPO AVE ACTUALLY KEEPS IT MORE AT THE SAME ELEVATION BECAUSE IT TENDS TO FOLLOW THE STREET SCAPE AS WELL. AND THEN WE HAVE ALMOST THE SAME THING OUT ON ROUTE 202 AROUND PO VALLEY ROAD, WHERE WE DID THE SITE DISTANCES. WE KNOW WE'RE GOING TO LOSE SOME EVERGREENS OUT THERE, SO WE KNOW WE'RE GOING TO BE DOING PLANTINGS BY WAY OF THE SIGHT LINES. AND THIS WILL BE ALL STAKED OUT AND CERTIFIED DURING CONSTRUCTION FOR AN ASPHALT WHEN IT COMES BACK INTO THE TOWN. OKAY. AND I HAVE A SIMILAR QUESTION ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE PROPERTY, I GUESS THE NORTH EAST, BUT SO IS THAT IS YOUR TESTIMONY THEN THAT IT IS FEASIBLE? YES. OKAY. YES. YEAH. YEAH. YES. OKAY. THANK YOU. YEAH, YEAH. SO NOW I'LL ASK THE OTHER FEASIBLE QUESTION ON THE OTHER SIDE. SO MY OBSERVATION ON THE OTHER SIDE WAS THIS IS THE NORTHEAST SIDE. SO I GUESS FACING THE THE HOTEL, THE NORTHEAST IS THE PROPERTY LINE. OKAY. IF I, IF I'M, LET ME JUST TRY TO ORIENT IF I'M ON IF I'M ON RAMAPO VALLEY ROAD AND I'M LOOKING INTO THE PROPERTY, THIS IS BASICALLY I'M LOOKING AT THE FRONT OF THE TEMPLE, THE PARKING LOT, THE FRONT OF THE TEMPLE, IF I'M THERE ON MY LEFT IS THE HOTEL.

YES. YEP. SO ALONG I'M JUST AGAIN, I'M LOOKING AT THE DIAGRAM AND I'M THINKING ABOUT WHAT I SAW, WHICH IS ON THE DIAGRAM. THE FENCE LOOKS LIKE IT'S RIGHT ALONG THE THE PARKING LOT. THERE ARE A LOT OF TREES THERE. YEAH. SO HOW ARE YOU GOING TO HOW ARE YOU GOING TO HOW ARE YOU GOING TO HANDLE THAT? THAT'S MY QUESTION. WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO DEAL WITH THAT BY WAY OF EITHER REMOVING THOSE TREES THAT ARE THERE NOW, OR WHICH A LOT OF THEM ARE VERY TALL AND THE LOWER LIMBS ARE ALREADY DEAD, RIGHT? SO EITHER REMOVE THEM OR TRIM THEM BACK AND PLANT THE FIVE FOOT ARBORVITAE IN FRONT OF THEM. THAT WILL BE DEALT WITH THOUGH.

AND THAT'S ONE OF THE QUESTIONS, DETAILS I HAD WITH DINESH WAS A LOT OF THESE ARE OLD AND DEAD AND THEY NEED TO COME DOWN ANYWAY, RIGHT? SO WE'RE GOING TO BE BASICALLY UPBRINGING UPGRADING IT. IT'S NICE IF YOU COULD CUT IT UP CUT THEM UP THOUGH, RIGHT? BECAUSE THEN YOU'LL HAVE MULTIPLE LAYERS OF PRIVACY. YES. YOU'LL HAVE HI. AND IF WE COULD, AND THAT'S WHY WE WENT WITH THE FIVE FOOT HIGH FENCE. BECAUSE IF WE CUT THEM MAYBE UP TO SEVEN AND WE PUT THE FIVE FOOT HIGH TREE IN, I'M SORRY, NOT FENCE, THEN THAT'LL GROW INTO THAT GREENERY THAT GOES HIGHER. SO I JUST HAD A FOLLOW UP TO THAT, WHICH IS GOING BACK TO PRIOR TESTIMONY, WHICH SAYS THAT ALL THE TREES WILL BE INSIDE THE FENCE. IS THAT ALSO TRUE IN THAT AREA? NO, THAT ISN'T BECAUSE WE HAVE THAT'S AN ISLAND BETWEEN THE TWO CURVED AREAS. THAT'S WHY WE HAVE TO CUT THEM BACK. SO THOSE TREES ARE ON THE OTHER PROPERTY. YES. THE NEW ONES WILL BE IN ALONG IN ALONG THE FENCE THOUGH. OKAY. SO THEY DON'T BELONG TO THE APPLICANT. RIGHT. SO I GUESS THE ANSWER SOME OF THIS IS GOING TO BE DIFFICULT, BUT ALL OF THIS IS IN YOUR MIND FEASIBLE. YES. IT'S GOING TO BE DIFFICULT. IT'S GOING TO TAKE SOME THINKING, A THOUGHT PROCESS. BUT YES, IT IS VERY EASY TO DO. OKAY. THANK YOU. AND WHEN IT'S DONE IT'LL IT'LL ALL BLEND IN TOGETHER. THAT'S THE WHOLE IDEA. WE DO A LOT OF THESE AND LIKE I SAID, SOME OF THE UPPER SCALE HOMES THAT PUT THE PIERS AND THE FENCES, AND THIS IS PRETTY MUCH THAT BLACK WROUGHT IRON FENCE, BUT IT'S REALLY ALUMINUM. IT'S BLACK ALUMINUM, WHICH IS EASIER TO WORK WITH, AND IT LOOKS JUST AS NICE. THANK YOU. GOOD. ALL RIGHT, MR. MOLFETTA, THE SITE PLAN THAT WE'RE LOOKING AT, DOES THIS INCLUDE THE PROPOSED NEW CONSTRUCTION? NO IT DOESN'T.

[00:50:02]

AND THAT HASN'T STARTED YET. OKAY. AND ALONG THE BACK WHERE CLARK AVENUE IS WHERE YOU'RE ELECTING TO DO THE CHAIN LINK, I'M ASSUMING THAT THERE ARE HOUSES THAT BACK UP TO THAT WITH THEIR BACKYARDS. YES. I BELIEVE THERE'S ONE HOUSE OF WHICH I THINK THE FELLOW HERE IS LIVES THERE. AND I GUESS THE REASON I ASKED THAT QUESTION IS BECAUSE IF SAFETY IS A CONCERN AND THIS IS A THIS IS A NON-SCALABLE FENCE, THE IRON ONE, BUT THE CHAIN LINK IS SCALABLE, RIGHT? SO I'M ASSUMING THAT MAYBE THE THE OWNERS BEHIND YOU MIGHT HAVE FENCING THAT WOULD PREVENT PEOPLE FROM ENTERING THEIR BACKYARD. AND I KNOW IT SEEMS ANNOYING AND I KNOW IT'S A HUGE UNDERTAKING COST WISE, BUT IF SAFETY WAS A TRUE CONCERN, I WOULD THINK THAT YOU'D WANT THAT WROUGHT IRON LOOK OR THAT BLACK ALUMINUM AROUND THE WHOLE THING FOR THAT. UNLESS, OF COURSE, THERE'S PRIVACY FROM THE HOUSES BEHIND YOU. AND THAT'S JUST SO WHAT'S THE EXACT QUESTION? SO THE QUESTION IS, IF THE NEIGHBORS BEHIND THEM HAVE OPEN PROPERTIES THAT WOULD PROVIDE ACCESS TO THE BACK OF THE FENCE, SHOULD IT BE REQUIRED THAT THE FENCING BE ALSO SOMETHING THAT WOULD BE CONSIDERED NON-SCALABLE TO PREVENT ACCESS TO THE PROPERTY? OKAY, SO IN RESPONSE TO THAT, THIS REPORT FROM HOMELAND SECURITY SUGGESTS CHAIN LINK FENCE OR THE FENCE. WE'RE PROPOSING ONE OR THE OTHER. SO THEY DON'T HAVE A CONCERN. THAT CHAIN LINK. I DID JUST AS AN ASIDE, I DID 6 OR 8 APPLICATIONS FOR RIDGEWOOD WATER DEPARTMENT WITH FENCING THAT HAD TO BE SIX FEET IN HEIGHT BY HOMELAND SECURITY FOR RIDGEWOOD WATER IN THE VARIOUS TOWNS WHERE THEIR PUMP STATIONS ARE, BECAUSE THERE'S A CONCERN NOW WITH SECURITY THAT ONE OF THEM COULD BE COMPROMISED IN THE WATER SYSTEM, COULD BE COMPROMISED. SO I DID MIDLAND PARK, WYCKOFF, WALDWICK, FRANKLIN LAKES, SO AND THEY ARE ALL GOT CHAIN LINK FENCE, NOTHING ELSE. SO THE HOMELAND SECURITY SAYS THEY WILL WORK ANYTHING ELSE. SO YEAH, JUST TO CONTINUE DOWN THAT BECAUSE IT DOES THE REPORT STIPULATE IN ANY WAY WHY THEY FEEL LIKE THAT FENCE, THE CHAIN LINK OR THE ALUMINUM SIX FOOT THAT WE'RE LOOKING AT HERE ARE A DETERRENT, ONE OR THE OTHER. AND I'M JUST, IT ALMOST FEELS LIKE THERE SHOULD BE MORE OR SOMETHING THAT CAN'T BE SCALED. LIKE LITERALLY SOMETHING I DON'T WANT TO SAY, LIKE BARBED WIRE, THAT'S A LITTLE MUCH, BUT LIKE, WELL, LIKE THERE ARE SOME FACILITIES WITH WATER DEPARTMENTS THAT HAVE BARBED WIRE THAT THEY DID NOT REQUIRE THAT HERE. SO THEY FEEL AS THOUGH THAT THOSE TYPES OF FENCES. YEAH, ORDINARY CHAIN LINK FENCE CONSTITUTES A LEGAL BOUNDARY AROUND THE FACILITY AND PROVIDES A MEAN OF POSTING SIGNS REGARDING TRESPASSING, SECURITY MEASURES AND EVEN DEADLY FORCE. I'M NOT GIVING AWAY ALL THE THINGS THEY WANT DONE, BUT I'M JUST TELLING YOU WHAT THEIR OBSERVATION IS. YEAH, OKAY. WELL, SO THE FENCE ISN'T GOING TO STOP ANYBODY FROM GETTING THE PROPERTY. IT'S GOING TO SLOW THEM DOWN. THAT'S WHAT IT'S REPORT. YES. SO THAT'S A THAT'S THE ANSWER. YEAH. IT'S A DETERRENT. IT'S A DETERRENT. BUT AND YOU WANT TO GET IN. YEAH. OKAY. AN ALARM ON YOUR HOUSE. I'LL GIVE YOU THE ANSWER TO THAT. OUT OF THE REPORT. HOWEVER, SUCH FENCES DO NOT POSE A SERIOUS OBSTACLE TO A DEDICATED ADVERSARY RIGHT OUT OF HOMELAND. YEAH. OKAY. MAYBE A TEN FOOT WALL. OKAY. MR. KASPARIAN, PLEASE. JUST ONE FOLLOW UP QUESTION, SIR. WHAT IS THE LOCKING MECHANISM GOING TO BE USED AT THIS GATE AS A DETERRENT? IT'LL BE A TYPICAL LOCK BOX WITH A TYPICAL LOCK. I'M NOT SURE WHAT IT IS, BUT IT'LL BE. KNOX BOX IS MEANT TO BE SECURED FOR LOCKING KEYS FOR. THAT'S CORRECT. AND THAT WILL MEET THE STANDARDS FOR WHATEVER WE NEED TO DO. NO THAT'S FINE. HOW ARE THE GATES BEING LOCKED? THE GATES ARE GOING TO BE POWER, I BELIEVE. ARE THEY NOT POWER. OH THEY'RE NOT THE LOCK. THEY.

OKAY. THAT'S THE ANSWER I DIDN'T THE PRIEST WILL LOCK THE GATES MANUALLY. RIGHT. WHAT WHAT IS IT A PADLOCK? HE'S ASKING IS IT A LOCKED PADLOCK? YEAH, YEAH. PLEASE HOLD ON, MR. CHAIRMAN. YEAH. CAN JP NOT COMMENT. YEAH. THE APPLICANT PROVIDE THEIR TESTIMONY AND.

YEAH. AND I WAS JUST I WAS I WAS JUST SAYING THE SAME THING. JUST EVERYONE'S GOT TO LET THE QUESTION BE ASKED AND THE WITNESS ANSWER THE QUESTION. SO MR. KASPARIAN IS ASKING ABOUT HOW THE GATE WILL BE LOCKED, AND IT HASN'T BEEN DISCUSSED YET, BUT WE'RE WILLING TO WORK WITH THE TOWN. HOWEVER WE HAVE TO TO MAKE IT WORK TO SATISFY YOUR PROFESSIONALS. MY, MY QUESTION REALLY IS, IS THAT THESE GATES. NOW I HAVE THESE GATES AROUND MY YARD. A TYPICAL RESIDENTIAL. IT'S JUST A LITTLE. IT'S A POOL LOCK GATE. SO YOU JUST PULL THE MAGNETIC MECHANISM. EVEN IF I WAS TO PUT A CHAIN AROUND IT, THE HINGES ARE PLASTIC. YEAH. THIS PROBABLY WILL NOT HAVE A CHAIN. IT WILL PROBABLY HAVE TWO GATES THAT GO TOGETHER. THEY'RE GOING TO BE LONG GATES BECAUSE WE GOT A WIDE DRIVEWAY HERE. WE STILL HAVE TO GET APPROVAL. ALTHOUGH WE HAVE APPROVAL, WE STILL HAVE TO GET PERMISSION FROM YOUR POLICE, YOUR EMS AND YOUR

[00:55:05]

AMBULANCE CORPS. SO WE WILL DO WHATEVER. RIGHT. SO MY CONCERN IS, IS FOR THE PROPERTY. YEAH.

OKAY. MY CONCERN FOR THE PROPERTY, YOU'RE GOING THROUGH THIS LARGE EXPENSE, THIS LARGE AND AND I UNDERSTAND THE SENSITIVITY BECAUSE I TO BELONG TO A PARISH OF OF, YOU KNOW, RELIGIOUS. SO THE CONCERN IS, YES, YOU HAVE THIS ALUMINUM GATE. IT'S OBVIOUSLY NOT GOING TO BE A DEADBOLT OR SOMETHING WE WOULD HAVE IN OUR HOME OR SOMETHING. SO IF YOU'RE GOING TO WRAP CHAIN AROUND IT NOW, YOU'RE GOING TO MAR THE LOOKS OF THE FENCE AND EVERYTHING, WHICH THIS FENCE CANNOT SUPPORT THAT. SO I'M JUST CURIOUS, AS I CAN IMAGINE, WITH THE MONEY THEY'RE SPENDING ON THIS FENCE, THAT THEY'RE GOING TO WRAP A CHAIN AND DO A HAND LOCK AROUND IT, I WOULD IMAGINE MY CONCERN, MY CONCERN IS SECURITY BECAUSE YOU'RE GOING THROUGH THIS BIG EXPENSE AND THIS BIG ORDEAL, THAT OF DOING A SIX FOOT FENCE TO KEEP OUT YOUR DETERRENTS.

YEAH. YOU WANT TO MAINTAIN AND KNOW THAT THE LOCKING MECHANISM IS AS SECURE AS YOUR FENCING IS AROUND THE ENTIRE PROPERTY. RIGHT. AND THAT'S, THAT'S THE WAY THIS WILL BE BE DEALT WITH AT THE TIME OF PERMITTING. WE WILL DEFINITELY HAVE THE LOCKS AND THE SECURITY AND THE LOCK BOX ALL UP TO A GOOD STANDARD. THERE'S NO THE KNOX BOX HAS TO GET BOLTED TO SOMETHING. YEAH.

HE'S GONNA HE'S GONNA FROM THE GROUND OR SOMETHING. YEAH. I THINK TO WHAT HE'S SAYING IS, AND CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG, BUT THAT HE WILL GO THROUGH THE NECESSARY, NECESSARY PROTOCOLS TO MAKE SURE THAT IT'S SECURE BECAUSE IT'S, IT'S A LITTLE BIT OUTSIDE OF OUR PURVIEW. IT'S EVEN OUTSIDE OF MINE BECAUSE I'M NOT AN EXPERT ON GATES AND LOCKS AND THAT, BUT WE WILL HAVE OUR EXPERT WHEN THEY PUT THE FENCE IN, DEAL WITH THE TOWN AND COME UP TO WHATEVER STANDARD. THANK YOU, MR. JULIET. JUST TO. MR. KAHANA ALSO WAS HEAD OF SECURITY IN NEW YORK CITY'S GOVERNMENTAL FACILITIES. THANK YOU. DID YOU HAVE A QUESTION, MR. TAYLOR? JUST FOR THE FOR THE BOARD. I MEAN, JUST TO BRING US BACK TO THE CENTER, OUR JOB IS TO LOOK AT THE VARIANCE, NOT TO LOOK AT THE SECURITY AND THE FEASIBILITY. AND IT'S OUR JOB TO LOOK AT THE MERITS OF THE VARIANCE. WE'RE GETTING WE'RE COMING BACK. MR. KASPARIAN HAS HAD SOME QUESTIONS. IT'S ALL RIGHT. ALL RIGHT. SO GOING BACK, ONE OF THE THINGS I WANTED TO UNDERSTAND BETTER IS COMING DOWN WEST RAMAPO AVENUE TOWARDS RAMAPO VALLEY ROAD. EVERYONE HERE KNOWS ANYONE WHO'S EVER MADE THAT TURN. PEOPLE COME FLYING ON THAT ROAD. THERE'S A LOT OF TRAFFIC. PEOPLE ARE MOVING VERY FAST. CAN YOU JUST TALK US THROUGH THE SIGHT LINE AND HOW YOU'RE DESIGNING THE FENCE, OR HOW THE FENCE IS GOING TO BE CONSTRUCTED SO THAT IT'S NOT AN ISSUE? YEAH. WE DID NOT ONLY A HORIZONTAL MEASUREMENT WE REQUIRE THE COUNTY REQUIRES 500FT. SO IF YOU TAKE THAT SHADED AREA IN THE INTERSECTION, YOU'LL SEE IT GOES ALL THE WAY OUT TO ALMOST THE MIDDLE OF THE STREET, WHICH WE CAN SEE. AND THAT'S TAKEN DOWN THE CENTER LINE OF OF VALLEY ROAD, ROUTE 202. MR. DOOLITTLE, I'M SORRY, CAN YOU JUST COME UP AND POINT FOR ME WHILE YOU'RE DOING IT? THANK YOU. BECAUSE THIS IS THIS IS THE MOST PROBABLY THE MOST IMPORTANT POINT. YES. YEAH. THIS IS THE SITE TRIANGLE HERE FOR A CAR COMING UP AND PULLING OUT AND GOING SOUTH. THIS IS THE HORIZONTAL DIMENSION WHICH IS REQUIRED TO BE 500FT, WHICH WE HAVE. THIS IS THE PROFILE WEST. THIS IS THE PROFILE HERE.

SO THAT WHEN YOU LOOK DOWN, IF THERE'S A HIGH SPOT OR SOMETHING IN THE WAY, LIKE TREES, THEY HAVE TO BE REMOVED. THAT'S WHY WE'VE TAKEN THIS LINE FROM THIS POINT STRAIGHT THROUGH HERE. AND WE'RE KEEPING THE FENCE BACK INSIDE OF THAT. OKAY, SO THE FENCE WON'T INTERRUPT THAT SIGHT LINE OF 500FT. FOR THE RECORD, HOW FAR WOULD A CAR THAT STOPPED AT THE WHITE HASH MAKING A LEFT? HOW FAR OUT PAST THE FENCE WOULD THEY BE? WELL, THIS IS ACTUALLY RIGHT AT THE FENCE, SO THEY WOULD BE THE FRONT OF THE CAR WOULD BE ABOUT 8 OR 10FT PAST THAT, WHICH IS STILL NOT EVEN IN THE CARTWAY OF THE 202. OKAY, MR. KELLY, YOU CONCUR. YES. AND I KNOW THEY OFFERED TO REVIEW IT WITH ME IN THE FIELD PRIOR TO INSTALLATION. I'D LIKE TO BE OUT THERE WHEN THE WHEN THE FENCE IS STAKED OUT AND THEN DURING INSTALLATION TO MAKE SURE THAT IT'S OUTSIDE OF A SITE DISTANCE SITE TRIANGLES AT THAT LOCATION. YES. OKAY. WE HAVE NO OBJECTION TO THAT. OKAY. OKAY. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT, GUYS, ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FOR MR. DOOLITTLE? THERE BEING NONE. EXPERTS. MR. KELLY, I GOT A FEW QUESTIONS. SO IF WE START WITH THE EASTERN PROPERTY LINE. SO THAT'S THE NEIGHBOR TO THE THE NEXT DOOR NEIGHBOR THERE WHERE YOU HAVE THE CHAIN LINK FENCE. SO WHAT ARE THE LIMITS OF THE CHAIN LINK FENCE? IS IT GOING TO BE THAT ENTIRE PROPERTY LINE? YES. IT'S GOING TO BE THAT PROPERTY LINE UP TO PROBABLY RIGHT ABOUT WHERE THE GATES START. OKAY. AND THEN THE GATE IS GOING TO BE THE DECORATIVE TYPE THAT'LL BE CONSISTENT WITH THE GATE OUT AT THE STREET AT IT TOO. OKAY, SO THE BOTH GATES ARE GOING TO BE THE DECORATIVE IRON. YES. IRON FENCE. IT'S THE ALUMINUM FENCE, BUT OKAY. AND THEN THE FENCE LINE. FIRST I'M GOING TO ASK THAT YOU MARK, YOU HAVE THAT PROPERTY LINE

[01:00:03]

DELINEATED IN THE FIELD BEFORE YOU INSTALL THE FENCE. ABSOLUTELY. AND I KNOW THERE'S A ROW OF EVERGREEN BUFFERS IN THAT AREA EXISTING. AND WE'VE HAD THEY'VE DIED OFF OVER THE YEARS AND THE TEMPLE'S REPLACED THEM AND THINGS LIKE THAT. SO IS THAT IS THIS FENCE GOING TO BE ON THE THE OTHER SIDE OF THOSE ARBORVITAE? YES. I BELIEVE THE CHURCH IS PLANTED A LOT ALONG THAT PROPERTY LINE, AND THAT FENCE WILL BE ON THE OUTSIDE OF THAT. AND THERE'S ENOUGH ROOM BETWEEN THE EXISTING TREES OR BUFFER THERE AND THE PROPERTY LINE. IF NOT, WE WILL REMOVE THEM AND REPLACE THEM. OKAY. YEAH. ALL RIGHT. AND WE DON'T WANT TO ZIGZAG THE FENCE. WE WANT IT TO GO STRAIGHT AND THEN MAKE THE TREES FIT INTO IT APPROPRIATELY.

OKAY. AND IF THAT'S THE CASE, IF YOU'RE GOING TO REMOVE ANY OF THOSE TREES IN THAT AREA, IF THIS GETS APPROVED, I WOULD RECOMMEND A CONDITION OF APPROVAL THAT IT BE REVIEWED BY MY OFFICE. AND IF ADDITIONAL PLANTINGS ARE REQUIRED, THAT THAT THE TEMPLE AGREE TO PUT IN THOSE PLANTINGS AS REQUESTED. YEAH, WE'RE FINE WITH THAT. OKAY. NOW WHEN WE GET TO CLARK CLARK AVE. YOU SEE ON YOUR PLAN WHERE YOU HAVE OLD D LINE? YEP. IS THAT THE TEMPLE'S PROPERTY LINE OR IS THE PROPERTY LINE PERPENDICULAR ACROSS CLARK AVE? I THINK THAT LINE WAS THERE PRIOR TO CLARK AVE BEING INSTALLED AND WHY THAT GOT LEFT ON HERE, I DON'T KNOW BECAUSE THE VACATION ARE PROPERTY GOT THE WHOLE THING WHERE IN MOST CASES A VACATION IT GOES 5050 TO EACH PROPERTY. FOR SOME REASON IT DIDN'T GO TO THE CHURCH, TO THE MOTEL PROPERTY.

SO WE WOUND UP HAVING THAT BEND IN THAT LITTLE EXTRA TRIANGLE IN THERE. SO YOUR THE OLD LINE IS, IS JUST REALLY FOR THE SURVEY PURPOSE. BUT WE OWN THAT LITTLE TRIANGLE. THAT TRIANGLE.

OKAY. YEAH. GOOD, GOOD. I THINK THAT MAKES IT EASIER WITH RESPECT TO APPROVALS FROM THE TOWN, I CAN TELL YOU THE WAY THE PROCESS WORKS TO GET APPROVAL TO PUT A FENCE IN AN EASEMENT. IT'S A REQUEST THAT GOES TO CLARK, THAT GOES TO THE COUNCIL, AND THEN THEY ASK THE OPINION OF MYSELF, THE WATER AND SEWER DEPARTMENT AND THE DPW IF WE HAVE ANY ISSUES WITH IT. I. I DO NOT HAVE ANY ISSUES WITH THE FENCE CROSSING OUR EASEMENT IN THAT LOCATION OR THESE LOCATIONS, WITH THE CAVEAT IT'S ALWAYS PUT IN THE AGREEMENT THAT SHOULD WE NEED ACCESS TO OUR UTILITIES, WE'RE GOING TO GET ACCESS TO THEM, AND WE'RE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY DAMAGE TO ANY FENCES OR ANYTHING THAT THAT'S IN OUR EASEMENT. WE'RE NOT REQUIRED.

THEY'RE GOING TO GET DAMAGED. WE'RE NOT REQUIRED TO REPLACE THEM. THAT'S UP TO THE PROPERTY OWNER. NOW, IF WE GO ALONG THE NORTH PROPERTY LINE, THE SHARED PROPERTY LINE WITH THE HOTEL, I KNOW YOU HAVE, THERE ARE SOME THE BUFFER THERE IS A SUBSTANTIAL BUFFER. YEAH.

BEFORE ANY TREES ARE REMOVED, I'D LIKE TO MEET OUT THERE BECAUSE I THINK FOR EVERYBODY, I KNOW THAT THE TEMPLE'S NOT LOOKING TO REMOVE TREES. IF THEY DON'T NEED TO BE REMOVED.

THE TEMPLE WANTS A BUFFER AS MUCH AS EVERYBODY ELSE WANTS A BUFFER. SO I KNOW IT'S EVERYBODY'S INTENT TO KEEP THE BUFFER AS BOUNTIFUL AS AS POSSIBLE. SO I JUST WANT TO I'D LIKE TO BE OUT THERE WHEN WE WHEN YOU GUYS LAY THIS OUT SO THAT WE HAVE NO ISSUES WITH. I DON'T WANT EXCESSIVE TREE REMOVAL. I DON'T THINK MY CLIENT HAS A PROBLEM WITH THAT.

RIGHT. AND I KNOW YOUR CLIENT DOESN'T WANT TO REMOVE TREES IF THEY'RE NOT REQUIRED TO BE REMOVED. BUT, YOU KNOW, WE WE'D LIKE TO KEEP THE, THE BUFFERS BEAUTIFUL. IT'S, IT'S SUBSTANTIAL. SO WE WOULD JUST LIKE TO TAKE A LOOK AT THAT AS WELL. I LIKE THE FACT THAT THEY'RE GOING TO GRANT US AN EASEMENT FOR OUR WATER MAIN ALONG THE SOUTH SIDE, THAT THAT WILL BE A GOOD BENEFIT TO THE TOWN. AND THAT'S REALLY ABOUT IT. I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE GET. I'M NOT AS CONCERNED ABOUT THE PROPERTY LINE FOR THE HOTEL, BECAUSE I KNOW YOU GUYS ARE GOING TO BE WE CAN JUST GO BASED OFF THE CURB LINE. YOU KNOW, WE KNOW WE'RE GOING TO BE YOU'RE GOING TO BE TWO FEET NORTH OF THE CURB LINE. WE HAVE ALREADY STAKED THE ENTIRE PROPERTY, AND IT WILL BE STAKED FOR THIS CONSTRUCTION. OKAY. AND, MR. PRESIDENT, THAT'S ALL I HAVE. OKAY. THANK YOU, MR. KELLY, DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING? I HAVE NOTHING, THANK YOU. OKAY.

ALL RIGHT. ANY. OH, MR. GRAF, DID YOU WANT TO ASK QUESTIONS OF THE ENGINEER? YES. YEAH. MR. DOOLITTLE, CAN YOU. YEAH. THANK YOU. SORRY. THE QUESTION ALONG OUR PROPERTY LINE, THAT'S GOING TO BE CHAIN LINK. YES. OKAY. YOU SAID THAT YOU'RE GOING TO BE REMOVING TREES IF THEY'RE IN THE WAY. CORRECT. IF THEY'RE ON OUR PROPERTY AND IN THE WAY. YES, I CAN TELL YOU RIGHT NOW, AS OUR US TWO AND MR. KELLY SPOKE YEARS AGO, BEFORE WE GOT RID OF ALL THE PINES AND PUT IN THOSE, OUR BODIES THAT ARE NOW 15, 20FT TALL AND CREATE A GREAT BUFFER, THEY ALL HAVE TO

[01:05:02]

COME OUT. ONCE WE GET THE LOT LINE STAKED, WE CAN HAVE A SITE MEETING OUT THERE AND DECIDE HOW WE GET IT THROUGH THERE. WE'RE NOT LOOKING TO, LIKE YOU SAID, LIKE DENY SAID HE DOESN'T WANT TO PAY TO TAKE TREES DOWN. NO, I DON'T EITHER. AND THEY ACTUALLY FINALLY GREW IN TO MAKE A NICE BUFFER. THE ONLY ONES THAT WERE CONCERNED ABOUT WERE THE. THE DEAD SPRUCES AT THE END WERE COVERED IN VINES. BUT THAT'S ALL GOING TO BE CHAIN LINK AND THE CHAIN LINK IS GOING TO BE ON MY. I'M GOING TO BE ON MY SITE TO SEE IT. AND THE TREES ARE GOING TO BE ON YOUR SIDE, GOING TO BE ON YOUR SIDE BECAUSE WE'RE TRYING TO KEEP ALL THE EVERGREENS INSIDE.

IF YOU HAVE THEM ON YOUR SIDE, WE'RE NOT TOUCHING THEM. NO, NO, I JUST HAVE THE ONES THAT YOU PLANTED. YES. IS THE TEMPLE AGAINST FROM THE MIDPOINT? BECAUSE I HAVE THAT FOUR FOOT BLACK CHAIN LINK THAT I PUT IN TO GO WITH THE WROUGHT IRON. AND WHERE DOES IT HIT? IN THE CORNER PROPERTY UP BY THE STREET. YEAH, I DON'T KNOW. I HAVEN'T GONE ON YOUR PROPERTY TO LOCATE YOUR FENCE. IT'S HALFWAY, IT'S MID MID PROPERTY. THAT COULD BE ALSO A DISCUSSION WHEN WE COME OUT TO PROPERTY WITH THE TOWN ENGINEER AND OUR CLIENT. AND WHERE DOES IT HIT UP FRONT? LIKE WHERE MY DRIVEWAY AND THE WHERE YOU SAY UP FRONT OUT ON WEST RAMAPO VALLEY AVE OR CLARK. NO, WEST RAMAPO. THAT'S MY ENTRANCE. MY DRIVEWAY IS RIGHT ON THE PROPERTY LINE TO. YEAH, WELL, WE'LL SEE THAT WHEN WE STAKE. AND I DON'T HAVE YOUR DRIVEWAY ON OUR DRAWING, SO I WOULD IMAGINE IT'S PROBABLY A LITTLE BIT FURTHER EAST. I DO SEE A SPOT THAT TENDS TO FLATTEN OUT HERE, AND WE'RE CERTAINLY NOT GOING TO PUT IT IN THE MIDDLE OF YOUR DRIVEWAY. YEAH, WE CAN PUT IT IN. MR. KELLY. YOU MIGHT WANT TO PUT THE LANGUAGE IN, BUT WE'LL PUT IT SUBJECT TO LIKE A MEETING WITH MR. KELLY, MR. DOOLITTLE AND YOURSELF.

PRECONSTRUCTION MEETING? YEAH. TO MAKE SURE THAT THIS ALL HAPPENS IN A WAY THAT WORKS.

RIGHT. BECAUSE MY ONLY. I DIDN'T MEAN TO INTERRUPT, BUT MY ONLY CONCERN IS, I THINK BEFORE I WAS INTO THE HOUSE, THE DRIVEWAY IS ACTUALLY ON THEIR PROPERTY. SO IF THEY BUILT THE PROPERTY, THEY PUT THE FENCE, IT WOULD ACTUALLY CUT MY DRIVEWAY IN A QUARTER OFF. OKAY. BUT THAT WAS BEFORE I BOUGHT THE PROPERTY. I DIDN'T DO THAT. YEAH. SO, MR. DOOLITTLE, WHAT DO YOU PROPOSE? WE COULD PULL THE FENCE IN IF WE HAVE TO PULL IT IN TO LEAVE HIS DRIVEWAY WHERE IT IS. I'LL LEAVE THAT UP TO MY CLIENT AND HIS ATTORNEY TO MAKE THAT DECISION, BUT IT CAN EASILY BE MOVED. OKAY, MR. WHITAKER? YEAH. WE HAVE TO LOOK AT THE SITE, BUT SEEMS AMENABLE TO THIS. DO THAT BY WAY OF A PRE-CONSTRUCTION MEETING WITH MIKE. AND IF THE NEIGHBOR WANTS TO BE THERE, THAT'D BE GREAT. YEAH. I'D LIKE TO BE THERE BECAUSE WOULD IT BE ADVANTAGEOUS TO DO WROUGHT IRON ON THE OPEN PART? LET'S WAIT TILL WE GET IT STAKED AND GET OUT THERE. OKAY? WE'LL ALL HAVE THAT CONVERSATION. BIG DONATION.

YEAH, YOU TRY. ALL RIGHT. I JUST DON'T WANT TO RUIN THE VALUE OF MY PROPERTY. NO.

TOTALLY UNDERSTOOD. AND, YEAH. MR. KELLY, GO AHEAD. RECOMMEND THAT THE CHAIN LINK FENCE BE A VINYL COATED POWDER COATED IN A COLOR THAT WILL BLEND IN EITHER BLACK, GREEN. IT'LL BE BLACK.

IT'LL BE BLACK TO MATCH THE REST OF THE. MAKE IT A BLACK POWDER COATED FENCE THAT'LL BLEND IN WITH THE LANDSCAPING. AND, YOU KNOW, IT'LL BE ALMOST INVISIBLE TO MOST PEOPLE. YEAH, THE ARBOR VALUES ARE ACTUALLY GROWING THROUGH MINE A LITTLE BIT, SO IT KIND OF BLENDS IT IN NICE. BUT I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY WHAT WE'RE GOING TO DO. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. CAN I LOOK AT THE DRAWING OR. YEAH GO AHEAD. THANK YOU, THANK YOU THANK YOU. HERE. I DON'T I DON'T NEED ANY MORE. THEY'RE ALL PUBLIC RECORD. SO YEAH. BUT THAT'LL KEEP YOU FROM HAVING TO GO TO THE TOWN.

ALL RIGHT. I LIKE IT HERE. ARE WE ALLOWED TO ASK FOR CONDITIONS FOR THAT OR. HE'S GOT SOME CONDITIONS. HE'LL READ THEM. AND IF THERE'S SOMETHING ELSE WE WANT TO TRY TO PUT IN, WE CAN DISCUSS IT AFTER HE READS THE CONDITIONS. OKAY. YEAH, HE'S GOT A BUNCH HERE, SO.

ALL RIGHT. ANY OTHER MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR MR. DOOLITTLE? ALL RIGHT.

THERE BEING NONE, MR. WHITAKER, THAT CONCLUDES OUR PRESENTATION. OKAY. I'M NOT GOING TO BELABOR IT. I BELIEVE THAT THE APPLICANT HAS PROPERLY PROVIDED SUFFICIENT DOCUMENTATION, TESTIMONY AND NEED FOR WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING. IT MEETS THE REQUIREMENTS UNDER THE MUNICIPAL LAND USE LAW FOR VARIANCE RELIEF. AS I STATED IN MY OPENING, AS IT PERTAINS TO THE SAFETY ASPECT, WHICH IS ONE OF THE GOALS AND VALUES OF THE MUNICIPAL LAND USE LAW RIGHT AT THE BEGINNING IN SECTION TWO OF THE MUNICIPAL LAND USE LAW FOR SAFETY. AND YOU'VE HEARD HERE THE NEED FOR. WE ALL RECOGNIZE. WE WISH THESE THINGS DIDN'T HAVE TO OCCUR. BUT IN TODAY'S WORLD, EVIDENTLY, THEY HAVE TO LOOK BACK WITHOUT SAYING IT'S ONLY IN MAHWAH ANYWAY. IF THOSE OF YOU RECALL, EIGHT YEARS AGO THIS DECEMBER, THE CHURCH IN FRANKLIN LAKES WAS BURNED TO THE GROUND BY ARSON. SO IT OCCURS ALL OVER. MOST BLESSED SACRAMENT. YEAH. GOOD. MR. WHITAKER, THEN? YEAH. I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE I DID. ANYONE WHO WANTS TO GIVE TESTIMONY FROM THE PUBLIC. BUT I DON'T THINK THAT'S THE CASE. OKAY. ALL RIGHT, ALL RIGHT, GUYS, LET'S MOVE INTO WORK SESSION. OKAY, MR. MOLFETTA, MR. SITAR SECOND. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. OKAY.

[01:10:01]

WE ARE IN WORK SESSION. I'LL JUST STATE FOR THE RECORD, GUYS, THIS SEEMS LIKE A PRETTY TO CLEAR C2 VARIANCE CASE. AS MR. WHITAKER JUST SAID, IT DOES ADVANCE THE PURPOSES OF THE MLUL FOR PURPOSES OF SAFETY, AND THERE IS NO SUBSTANTIAL HARM IN MY OPINION. IF ANYONE HAS ANYTHING THAT THEY WANT TO DISCUSS OR IF THEY DISAGREE, WE CAN HAVE THAT DISCUSSION. BUT TO ME IT FEELS PRETTY CLEAR CUT. SO WITH THAT, I'LL OPEN UP TO YOU GUYS. ALL RIGHT. I'LL START IT. YEAH. I UNDERSTAND THE NECESSITY OF THIS, AND I DO FEEL FOR THE APPLICANT. MY CONCERN IS FOR THE INITIAL FIRST 1 TO 5 YEARS, LET'S SAY, BEFORE LANDSCAPING GROWS IN POSSIBLE CONCERN OF COMMUNITY EYESORE, OF SEEING A SIX FOOT FENCE THAT GIVES OFF THAT APPEARANCE OF MORE OF A COMPOUND THAN JUST FACILITY. SO I'M JUST, YOU KNOW, I BELIEVE THEIR INTENTIONS ARE ALL IN THE RIGHT PLACE. AND THEIR GOAL IS TO FIRST MAINTAIN SECURITY AS WELL AS ESTHETIC AND NOT OFFEND THE NEIGHBORS OR THE AREA. SO I JUST HOPE THAT IT'S AFTERWARDS IN YEARS TO COME, IT GROWS IN. AND IT'S NO LONGER A SEEABLE ITEM. YEAH. FAIR ENOUGH. I THINK THAT'S PROBABLY THE THE ONLY CONCERN IS THE LOOK OF IT. RIGHT. SO DID YOU HAVE SOMETHING. BUT THEY'RE GOING TO USE FIVE FOOT ARBORVITAE ON A SIX FOOT FENCE. SO IT'S NOT GOING TO BE THAT DRAMATIC WHEN THEY START OUT, YOU KNOW, YOU SEE A LITTLE FENCE, BUT IT WON'T BE THAT. IT WON'T BE THAT DRAMATIC. I MEAN, RIGHT IN MY MIND. SO I'M NOT I'M JUST NOT AS CONCERNED ABOUT IT. FAIR ENOUGH. MY ONLY CONCERN IS FOR THAT BACK LINE. AND I KNOW THEY'RE SPENDING A FORTUNE, BUT I HAVE A PROPERTY LINED WITH ARBORVITAE AND THEY DON'T GROW THROUGH THE CHAIN LINK, BUT THEY WOULD GROW THROUGH BEAUTIFULLY ON THAT WROUGHT IRON LOOK. AND I THINK THEY WOULD DISAPPEAR EVENTUALLY AS THE TREES GOT BIGGER. AND SO MY SUGGESTION WOULD BE THAT WE ASK THEM TO MATCH THE FENCING AT THE BACK OF THE PROPERTY. OKAY, I KNOW WE MIGHT NOT BE ALLOWED TO DO THAT, BUT I JUST THINK VISUALLY, WHEN I HEARD THE TESTIMONY OF THE NEIGHBOR THAT HE SAID HE ALREADY HAS A BLACK CHAIN LINK FENCE ON HIS BACK OF HIS PROPERTY, SO TO PUT THEM BACK TO BACK TO CHAIN LINKS, IT'LL, IT WON'T BE AS TRANSLUCENT AS IT NORMALLY WOULD BE. AND I THINK THE WROUGHT IRON WOULD ALLOW THAT TO DISAPPEAR MORE EASILY. OKAY. DID YOU IS THAT WE'RE NOT GOING TO ASK, BUT BASED ON THE COMMENTS OF THE BOARD AND WORK SESSION, IF THE APPLICANT DECIDES THAT HE WANTS TO REVISE HIS PLAN TO ACCOMMODATE SOMETHING LIKE THAT, THEY HAVE THE RIGHT TO DO. BUT THEY PUT THEIR PRESENTATION IN, THEY CLOSED AND THAT'S IT. OKAY. YEAH. MR. TAYLOR, ANYTHING THIS IS RECOMMENDED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY, THE MAHWAH POLICE DEPARTMENT, THEY'VE HAD NUMEROUS INSTANCES ON THEIR PROPERTY. AND IF IT'S GOING TO MAKE THE CHILDREN, THE WOMEN AND THE PARISHIONERS OF THAT TEMPLE FEEL MORE SAFE. I'M NOT AS CONCERNED ABOUT THE ESTHETIC LOOK ON A BACK ROAD OR A MAIN ROAD WHEN YOU'RE GOING 45MPH TRYING TO GET FROM ONE PLACE TO THE OTHER. SO I'M ALL IN FAVOR. THEY SATISFY ALL THE HARDSHIPS FOR THE VARIANTS, AND I THINK THAT THEY'VE MORE THAN PUT FORTH THEIR CASE FOR GRANTING THIS. THANK YOU, MR. TAYLOR. COMING DOWN THIS WAY. YEAH, I, I AGREE AS WELL. THEY DEFINITELY SATISFIED ALL THE VARIANCES. AND SO I, I'M, I FEEL FOR ALL THE INSTANCES THAT THE INCIDENTS THAT THEY HAVE HAD. SO I DEFINITELY FEEL IN FAVOR OF IT AS WELL. YEAH. THANK YOU. YEAH. I JUST WOULD CONCUR WITH WHAT MR. WHITAKER SAID, WHICH IS IT'S THE TIME IN WHICH WE LIVE. AND IT'S UNFORTUNATE, YOU KNOW, IT'S JUST THAT SECURITY AND SAFETY IS IMPORTANT. SO CLEARLY THIS IS WHAT THE APPLICANT WANTS. AND I THINK IT MAKES A LOT OF SENSE FOR FOR THEIR NEEDS. SO I WOULD BE IN FAVOR OF IT. THANK YOU. YEAH. AND I THINK THAT'S WELL SAID MR. TAYLOR. I THINK THAT IS EXACTLY ADVANCING THE PURPOSES OF THE MLUL IN TERMS OF SAFETY. SO I THINK AS A BOARD THIS IS A GOOD VARIANCE TO GRANT. MR. CHAIRMAN, JUST ONE CLARIFICATION. SO THEY'VE INDICATED THAT THEY'LL PUT PUT IN FIVE FOOT GREEN GIANT ARBORVITAE WHERE TREES ARE REMOVED. SO IT'S NOT GOING TO BE A CONDITION BECAUSE THERE ARE AREAS WHERE THERE'S NO TREES WHERE THEY'RE GOING TO BE PUTTING THE FENCE, SO THEY'RE NOT BUFFERING THE WHOLE ENTIRE FENCE WITH FIVE FOOT GREEN, GREEN, GIANT ARBOR VALUES. I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THAT'S THAT'S THE CASE. I DON'T WANT I DON'T WANT THIS TO GO IN. TREES ARE REMOVED. YEAH. I DON'T WANT THIS TO GO IN AND HAVE PEOPLE SAY, WELL, I THOUGHT THE WHOLE THING WAS GOING TO BE BUFFERED THAT THAT'S NOT. YEAH, THAT'S A GOOD POINT, MR. KELLY. LIKE IT WHEN YOU WHEN THEY DO, BECAUSE IT FEELS LIKE IT HASN'T BEEN FULLY FIGURED OUT YET, WHICH IS OKAY.

[01:15:04]

WILL THERE BE LIKE A LANDSCAPE PLAN OR IS IT KIND OF JUST GOING TO BE VERBAL BETWEEN ME VERBAL. WE'LL MEET OUT IN THE FIELD IF AND THE WAY I PICTURE THIS GOING IS THEY'RE GOING TO SAY, HEY, WE PROPOSE TO PUT THE FENCE HERE. IF THEY PUT THE FENCE THERE, IT'S GOING TO TAKE OUT A WHOLE ROW OF TREES. I THINK OUR DISCUSSION IS GOING TO BE LET'S LET'S SHIFT IT A LITTLE BIT TO AVOID HAVING TO TAKE OUT ALL THESE MATURE TREES IF WE CAN. YEAH, I'M NOT SAYING SHIFT IT 50FT, SHIFT IT, YOU KNOW, FOOT OR TWO WHERE YOU CAN SAVE ALL THOSE TREES. IF THERE'S AN AREA WHERE TREES HAVE A TREE HAS TO COME OUT BECAUSE OF THE LOCATION, THEN THAT'S WHERE THEY WOULD PROVIDE SOME ADDITIONAL BUFFERING. BUT I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THE BOARD DOESN'T THINK THAT THEY'RE PUTTING IN FENCE AND A ROW OF FIVE FOOT ARBORVITAE AROUND THE ENTIRE THING. THAT'S THAT'S NOT MY UNDERSTANDING. OKAY. OKAY. YEAH. GO AHEAD. I THOUGHT YOU SAID EARLIER THAT THAT ONE OF THE CONDITIONS WOULD BE THEY WOULD AGREE TO ADDITIONAL PLANTINGS. IF AFTER MEETING WITH YOU, YOU DETERMINED, THEY DETERMINED IT WAS NECESSARY. YOU DETERMINE IF I, I MEANT IN TERMS OF IF THEY'RE REMOVING TREES, PUT IN SOME ADDITIONAL TREES IN THAT AREA TO PROVIDE THE BUFFERING BACK, BUT WE, I, WE DO THAT PRETTY REGULARLY THAT, YOU KNOW, THAT WE'LL MEET WITH MIKE AND THEN IF THERE'S SOME ADDITIONAL PLANNINGS THAT HAVE TO GO IN, THE APPLICANT AGREES TO ACCOMMODATE ADDITIONAL PLANTINGS. SO I THINK THAT'S A GOOD CONDITION TO HAVE. YEAH. I THINK HE, HE, WE DO HAVE THAT AS A CONDITION. WHY DON'T YOU READ THE CONDITIONS, MR. CONTI? MR. WHITAKER STARTED OFF WITH STIPULATIONS THAT THE APPLICANT WILL OBTAIN A LICENSE AGREEMENT FOR CONSTRUCTION WITHIN OR INSTALLATION WITHIN THE ROAD WIDENING EASEMENT. THE SECOND ONE WAS OBTAIN A LICENSE AGREEMENT WITHIN THE SEWER SANITARY SEWER EASEMENT. THE KNOX BOX KNOX BOXES WILL BE LOCATED AS REQUIRED BY OR IN CONJUNCTION WITH COUNCIL WITH THE FIRE DEPARTMENT OR FIRE OFFICIAL. FIVE FOOT ARBORVITAE WILL BE INSTALLED WHERE TREES ARE REMOVED, BUT I BELIEVE THERE WAS ALSO A STIPULATION, MR. WHITAKER, THAT THE TEMPLE WOULD ALSO PLANT ADDITIONAL TREES AND OR LANDSCAPING AS REQUIRED BY THE BOARD ENGINEER. IS THAT CORRECT? THAT WOULD BE FINE. OKAY. THE APPLICANT WILL PROVIDE ACCESS TO THE TOWNSHIP FOR TO TOWNSHIP UTILITIES AND ANY OTHER. AND IF THERE'S ANY DAMAGE, THEN THAT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE OWNER.

THE STIPULATION THAT THIS IS APPROVAL WOULD BE SUBJECT TO A PRE-CONSTRUCTION MEETING WITH THE BOARD ENGINEER, ANY OTHER REQUIRED OFFICIALS, AND MR. GRAF, THE NEIGHBOR, AND THAT THEY WOULD INSTALL A VINYL. AND MR. KELLY, I THINK YOU SAID VINYL POWDER COATED, BLACK POWDER COATED. YES. WASN'T BLACK OR GREEN. IT WAS BLACK. BLACK POWDER COATED, BLACK POWDER COATED FENCE. OTHER. BLACK POWDER COATED CHAIN LINK FENCE. AND THAT WAS IT FOR STIPULATIONS. A COUPLE OF OTHERS TENDS TO BE MARKED OUT BEFORE INSTALLATION, AND THE GATES TO MATCH. THANK YOU, MR. WHITAKER. SO THAT WAS IT, MR. SITAR. IT IS A LITTLE BIT MORE VAGUE THAN MAYBE I THINK SOME OF THE BOARD MEMBERS WERE THINKING, BUT MR. KELLY IS PUTTING ON THE RECORD WHAT HE MEANT BY THE. BUT BUT BUT HE WILL BE ABLE TO SAY TO THEM, YOU NEED SOME SHIELDING. YES, BUT I TO MR. KELLY'S POINT. AND IF IT MATTERS TO WHICH WAY YOU VIEW OR DON'T VIEW THE. THE FENCE ITSELF IN TERMS OF ITS VARIANCE RELIEF THAT IT REQUIRES. IT PROBABLY WILL NOT END UP WITH A FULL GREEN WALL OF ARBORVITAES ALONG THE FENCE LINE, WHICH WOULD BE QUITE A BIT OF ARBORVITAES. AND HONESTLY, IN SOME OF THOSE AREAS, PROBABLY NOT FEASIBLE, BUT JUST FOR FOR CLARITY'S SAKE, THAT IS NOT WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN. OKAY. YEAH. OKAY. ANYBODY ELSE? NO. ALL RIGHT. SO DO I HAVE A BOARD MEMBER WHO WOULD LIKE TO MOVE THE APPLICATION WITH THE CONDITIONS, AS HAVE JUST BEEN READ INTO THE RECORD FOR APPROVAL? I'LL MAKE THE MOTION TO APPROVE WITH THE STIPULATIONS STATED FOR THE RECORD. OKAY. MR. TAYLOR, DO I HAVE A SECOND? I'LL SECOND. OKAY, MR. MOLFETTA, ROLL CALL.

VOTE, PLEASE, MR. KASPARIAN. NO. MR. LOCKWOOD. YES. MR. MOLFETTA. YES. MR. SERNA. YES. MR. SITAR.

YES. MR. TAYLOR. YES. MR. CANOVA. YES, THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. OKAY.

HAS BEEN APPROVED, MR. WHITAKER, YOU CAN LET YOUR APPLICANT KNOW. 45 DAYS AND. OKAY, GOOD. WE'VE

[01:20:07]

HAD FIVE APPLICATIONS BEFORE. YOU JUST WANT TO. GREAT. GOOD LUCK. OKAY. THANK YOU, THANK

[VII. WORK SESSION]

YOU. HAVE A GOOD EVENING, EVERYONE. ALL RIGHT. YOU AS WELL. ALL RIGHT, GUYS, WE'RE STILL IN WORK SESSION. WE'LL LET THEM CLEAR A BIT. AND THEN THERE'S A COUPLE THINGS WE WANT TO GO OVER. AGENDA. DO YOU WANT TO WE CAN TALK MEETING DATES. I DIDN'T HAVE A CHANCE TO LOOK AT THE CALENDAR. THE OTHER BOARD MEMBERS DID. I ALWAYS JUST WORRY ABOUT LIKE, OKAY, MOVE TO THE FOURTH. ALL RIGHT GUYS, SO LET'S START WITH NEW BUSINESS. WE'LL START WITH THE 2027 BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT, TENTATIVE MEETING DATES AS WE TRY TO NAIL DOWN THAT CALENDAR IS IS THERE ANY CONCERN OF THE DATES THAT MICHELLE'S PUT BEFORE US? ANY CONVERSATION? SHE SAID, I MEAN, WHY DON'T YOU YOU LOOKED INTO EASTER AND YOU LOOKED INTO SCHOOL BREAKS FOR SPRING BREAK, ALL THAT JEWISH HOLIDAYS. YES. SO. SO OKAY, I'M SURE ALL THESE DATES ARE OPEN RIGHT NOW. ALL RIGHT. GOOD. SO THEN I THINK WE'RE GOOD. MICHELLE, DO WE WANT TO DO JULY 7TH RIGHT AFTER THE FOURTH? JULY 4TH IS ON WHAT DAY? LET'S TAKE A LOOK SUNDAY BECAUSE THAT'S THE HOLIDAY WEEK THEN. YEAH. LET'S SEE WHAT'S THE FOURTH. FOURTH IS A SUNDAY. YEAH. SO IS IT TECHNICALLY A HOLIDAY WEEK OR NOT. I DON'T SHUT MY OFFICE ON THAT. I'LL I'LL GIVE MY PEOPLE MONDAY OFF.

YEAH. NO, I DON'T CARE. I JUST KNOW WE DON'T USUALLY DO THE HOLIDAY WEEKS. SO YEAH. NO I DON'T THINK I THINK I THINK WE'RE GOOD. YEAH. WE CAN ALWAYS LOOK TO KEEP, YOU KNOW THE AGENDA LIGHT OR NOTHING ON THAT MEETING. YEAH. YEAH. THERE WAS SOME DISCUSSION AROUND MAYBE TRYING TO IN THE SUMMER GET ALL THE APPLICATIONS INTO LESS MEETINGS. WE HAD A LITTLE BIT OF A IMPROMPTU MEETING ON THAT A COUPLE OF MEETINGS AGO. SO I THINK WE'LL LOOK TO DO THAT IF WE CAN. LABOR DAY EARLIER, LATE THIS YEAR. DO WE KNOW NEXT YEAR IT'S SEPTEMBER 6TH. IT'S A SECOND LATEST DATE. IT CAN BE. YEAH. YEAH. SO DO WE VOTE? ALL RIGHT. GREAT. LET'S DO IT. SO DO I HAVE SOMEONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO MOVE THE 2027 BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT? TENTATIVE MEETING DATES FOR APPROVAL AS MICHELLE HAS PRESENTED THEM. I'LL MOVE THEM. OKAY. MR. SITAR, DO I HAVE A SECOND? MR. KASPARIAN ROLL CALL, MR. KASPARIAN. YES. MR. LOCKWOOD, YES. MR. MOLFETTA.

YES. MR. SERNA. YES. MR. SITAR. YES. MR. TAYLOR. YES. MR. CANOVA. YES. OKAY, AND I APOLOGIZE. WERE YOU HERE FOR TO I I'M SORRY, I SHOULD HAVE INTRODUCED YOU. THIS IS ONE OF MY LAW PARTNERS WHO CAME AND SHE SITS ON A BOARD, REPRESENTS A BOARD, AND CAME UP TO SEE HOW WE DO IT. I JUST I FELT BAD. I'M LIKE, DID I MISS SOMETHING? OKAY, GOOD. NO, YOU'RE MYSELF TO EVERYONE ELSE, I GUESS YOU ARE COMPLETELY FINE. NO WORRIES. ALL RIGHT. SO OTHER NEW BUSINESS MR. LOCKWOOD BROUGHT TO MY ATTENTION, AND I WENT AND TOOK A LOOK MYSELF THAT THE SOLAR MARKET ON ROUTE 17 HAS CHANGED SOME OF THEIR SIGNAGE AROUND. WHY DON'T YOU TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT WHAT THE CONCERN WAS, AND THEN WE'LL LET MR. KELLY KIND OF RESPOND BECAUSE GAVE HIM A HEADS UP, GAVE MICHELLE AND JERRY A HEADS UP AS WELL. SO GO AHEAD. YEAH.

I DON'T DRIVE AROUND TOWN TRYING TO FIND STUFF. IT'S JUST I SEE THIS STUFF AS I'M GOING THROUGH TOWN. BUT I DID GO OVER TO WHAT WAS VALERO NOW BOLA MARKETS. AND WE APPROVED NEW SIGNAGE. SO THEY PUT THAT UP. THEY PUT UP THE THE NEW SIGNAGE AND BUT THEY HAVE A BUNCH OF TEMPORARY BANNERS THAT ARE ON THAT SIGNAGE. SO I JUST DON'T REMEMBER APPROVING ANY TEMPORARY BANNERS. AND THEY HAVE SOME OTHER AFFILIATION WITH ANOTHER COMPANY THAT THEY'RE ADVERTISING. SO I DID, I SAW THIS A COUPLE WEEKS AGO AND THEN I, I SAW IT YESTERDAY.

THEY ALSO NOW PUT UP, WHAT DO YOU CALL THEM, THE RIBBONS LIKE THE GRAND OPENING RIBBONS.

THEY'VE NOW THEY'VE GOT ADDED GRAND OPENING RIBBONS. SO BUNTING. BUNTING, BUNTING.

RIGHT. SO I DON'T EVEN RECALL IF TEMPORARY SIGNS ARE ALLOWED. MAYBE TEMPORARY SIGNS ARE ALLOWED, BUT I JUST THOUGHT I'D BRING IT TO THE ATTENTION OF THE BOARD. THE JUST LOOKED UNUSUAL. AND IT WASN'T WHAT I THOUGHT WE APPROVED. YEAH, WELL CERTAINLY NOT. I GUESS THE

[01:25:01]

QUESTION I HAD, AND I HAD THEM PULL THE ORDINANCE AND I READ THROUGH IT. SO I DIDN'T I DON'T KNOW WHAT KIND OF JURISDICTION WE HAVE OVER THAT AND WHATNOT. SO, MR. KELLY, WHY DON'T YOU TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THAT? YEAH. SO THE YOU KNOW, THERE ARE SOME TEMPORARY SIGNS THAT ARE PERMITTED, YOU KNOW, GRAND OPENINGS, THINGS LIKE THAT. HOWEVER, FOR THESE CANOPIES, I THINK IT IS A LITTLE DECEIVING BECAUSE IT ALMOST LOOKS LIKE IT'S PART OF THE CANOPY. THERE ARE TEMPORARY SIGNS THAT ARE ON THE CANOPY AND THEY'RE NOT ALLOWED. THIS HAS BEEN ON THE RADAR OF THE THE TOWNSHIP'S PROPERTY MAINTENANCE OFFICER. HE'S HE'S TRIED REACHING OUT TO THEM TO GET SOME CLARIFICATION ON WHAT THEY'RE DOING AND TO GET THEM TO TAKE IT DOWN. HE'S BEEN UNSUCCESSFUL WITH THAT. HE HAS ISSUED NOTICE OF VIOLATIONS TO TO THE PROPERTY OWNERS. THEY HAVE UNTIL A COMPLIANCE DATE OF OCTOBER 18TH. IF THEY DON'T COMPLY BY THAT DATE, THEN THEY'RE ISSUED SUMMONSES AND THEN THEY HAVE TO GO TO COURT. SO THAT THAT'S THE PROCESS THAT WE HAVE TO FOLLOW. IT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT, YOU KNOW, WE CAN HAVE OUR PROPERTY MAINTENANCE GUY GO OUT THERE AND TEAR THEM DOWN. YOU KNOW, WE HAVE TO GO THROUGH THE PROCESS, WHICH IS GIVE THEM A NOTICE. THEY HAVE TO TAKE CARE OF IT. YOU HAVE A COMPLY DATE, YOU DON'T COMPLY. THEN YOU GET A SUMMONS, THEN YOU HAVE TO GO TO COURT. AND ALL THAT CAN TAKE TIME. YOU KNOW THAT. UNFORTUNATELY, THAT CAN TAKE TIME. I'M I'M PRETTY CONFIDENT THAT KNOWING THE PROPERTY OWNER, THAT WE'LL BE ABLE TO GET THEM TO GET THIS ADDRESSED WITHOUT HAVING TO GO TO SUMMONS AND COURT ROUTE. BUT, YOU KNOW, IT IS IT IS SOMETHING THAT THE PROPERTY MAINTENANCE OFFICERS TAKING CARE OF. THANK YOU, MR. KELLY. YEAH, THANK YOU, MR. KELLY YEAH, THAT'S THAT'S GOOD NEWS. OKAY. GOOD GUYS. ANYTHING ELSE FOR NEW BUSINESS? NO, THERE BEING NONE. I DON'T BELIEVE WE HAD ANYTHING ELSE. UNLESS ANYONE ELSE HAS ANYTHING ELSE THEY WANT TO DISCUSS. OLD BUSINESS? NO. ALL RIGHT. SO WITH THAT, DO I HAVE SOMEONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO MOTION TO MOVE OUT OF WORK SESSION AND ADJOURN? I'LL MAKE A MOTION.

MR. SECOND, MR. TAYLOR, ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. OKAY. WE ARE OUT OF WORK. SESSION

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.