Link


Social

Embed


Download

Download
Download Transcript

[I.CHAIRMAN’S OPENING STATEMENT, FLAG SALUTE, ROLL CALL ]

[00:00:08]

REGULARLY SCHEDULED PUBLIC WORK SESSION MEETING OF THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT OF THE TOWNSHIP OF MAHWAH. ADEQUATE NOTICE OF THIS MEETING HAS BEEN PROVIDED BY PUBLICATIONS IN THE RIDGEWOOD NEWS, AND THE RECORD COPIES OF THE AGENDA HAVE BEEN FORWARDED TO THE TOWNSHIP CLERK AND POSTED ON THE MUNICIPAL BUILDING BULLETIN BOARD. THIS MEETING IS ALSO BEING RECORDED AND STREAMED ON THE MAHWAH LIVE VIDEO PAGE. LET'S DO THE FLAG SALUTE. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. SHALL. ROLL CALL, PLEASE. MR. HERE. MR. KASPARIAN HERE. MR. CARNEY IS ABSENT. MR. LOCKWOOD HERE. MR. MOLFETTA HERE. MR. SERNA ABSENT. MR. SITAR HERE. MR. TAYLOR ALSO ABSENT. AND MR. CANOVA HERE. OKAY. WE MOVE ON

[II.APPROVAL OF BILLS]

TO OUR APPROVALS OF THE BILLS. WE HAVE TWO BILLS TONIGHT WHICH WE CAN MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE OR NOT TOGETHER. ONE IS FOR AUGUST 2026. THE OTHER IS FOR SEPTEMBER 2026 FOR JOHN CONTEE, ESQUIRE. HELLO, JOHN. NICE TO BE HERE TO GET YOU PAID TONIGHT. ALL RIGHT. DO I HAVE SOMEONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO MOVE THESE TWO BILLS FOR APPROVAL? I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY, BOTH OF THESE ARE FOR TWO MEETINGS. SO IT'S LIKE WE'RE APPROVING FOUR MEETINGS. YES. YOU'RE APPROVING TWO BILLS THAT WERE FOR FOUR MEETINGS. THAT IS CORRECT. OKAY. YEP. IT'S NOT AN INCREASE IN RATES. YEAH. I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE THAT. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. MR. LOCKWOOD. DO I HAVE A SECOND? MR. CARLSON, ROLL CALL, MR. JONES. YES. MR. KASPARIAN. YES. MR. LOCKWOOD.

YES. MR. MOLFETTA. YES. MR. SITAR. YES. MR. CANOVA. YES. OKAY. THE BILLS HAVE BEEN

[III.APPROVAL OF MINUTES: October 7, 2026]

APPROVED. WE MOVE ON TO OUR APPROVAL OF MINUTES. WE HAVE ONE SET OF MINUTES TO REVIEW TONIGHT AND DISCUSS. THEY ARE FROM OUR LAST MEETING ON OCTOBER 7TH, 2026. WOULD ANYBODY LIKE TO HAVE ANY DISCUSSION ON THE MINUTES AS THEY HAVE BEEN RECORDED? I THINK THEY'RE FINE. OKAY. THANK YOU. SO WITH THAT, WOULD YOU LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO MOVE THEM? OKAY, MR. SITAR, FIRST, DO I HAVE A SECOND? SECOND. MR. KASPARIAN, ALL IN FAVOR? AYE.

OKAY. THE MINUTES FROM OCTOBER 7TH, 2026 HAVE BEEN APPROVED. ON TO OUR RESOLUTIONS. FOR

[IV.RESOLUTION FOR MEMORIALIZATION:]

MEMORIALIZATION, WE WILL START WITH DOCKET NUMBER 26-1624A. LOUISE PINHEIRO GUIMARAES AND ASHLEY JONES. I THINK I SAID THAT RIGHT? THIS WAS FOR DOCKET. I SAID THIS ALREADY. 3136 JOHNSON AVENUE, BLOCK 38. OKAY, GUYS, ANY CONVERSATION ON THE RESOLUTION AS IT HAS BEEN WRITTEN? OKAY. THERE BEING NONE, DO I HAVE SOMEONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO MOVE THE RESOLUTION FOR APPROVAL? I'LL MOVE IT. OKAY. MRS. SITAR, DO I HAVE A SECOND? I'LL SECOND. OKAY, MR. MOLFETTA, ROLL CALL PLEASE. MR. JONES, WAS I A MEETING? MR. YES. MR. LOCKWOOD. YES. MR. MOLFETTA.

YES. MR. SITAR. YES. MR. CANOVA. YES. OKAY. RESOLUTION FOR DOCKET NUMBER 261624 HAS BEEN APPROVED. OH, WAIT A MINUTE. I WAS AT THAT MEETING, SO. YES, YES. APOLOGIES. ALL RIGHT.

DOCKET NUMBER 26-1626. HINDU SAMAJ. GUYS, THIS WAS THE TEMPLE WITH THE FENCE THAT WE HEARD AND APPROVED AT THE LAST MEETING. I LOOKED THROUGH THIS ONE AND A LOT OF DETAIL BECAUSE THERE WAS A LOT WITH THE APPLICATION. I FOUND IT TO BE IN ORDER. I DON'T KNOW IF ANYONE ELSE HAD ANY COMMENTS. YEAH I DID, I DON'T HAVE ANY COMMENT. WELL, REAL COMMENTS, I JUST, YOU KNOW, WE DID. IT WAS I GUESS IT WAS IN MY MIND, IT WAS GOOD THAT WE DOCUMENTED LIKE WHY WE'RE DOING THIS, YOU KNOW, YOU KNOW, HE TOLD THE STORY OF ALL THE PROBLEMS THAT THEY HAD. YES. AND THAT'S BEEN DOCUMENTED. SO YES, ADVANCING THE SECURITY RIGHT ADVANCES THE MOU. WELL, WHICH MEETS THE CRITERIA, RIGHT? YEP. SO I JUST YEAH, THAT WAS THAT'S MY ONLY COMMENT. I THOUGHT IT WAS GOOD THAT WE HAD DOCUMENTED THE STORIES. I HAD A QUESTION THOUGH. I KNOW THAT WE HAD MADE A SUGGESTION OR I HAD MADE A SUGGESTION ABOUT NOT ALLOWING FOR THE CHAIN LINK FENCE TO BE IN THE BACK. AND I DIDN'T KNOW IF WE WERE ALLOWED TO MAKE THAT AS PART OF THE RESOLUTION, BECAUSE I FELT LIKE THEY WERE GETTING GRANT MONEY TO PUT THE FENCE IN. AND IT WAS A SMALL SECTION, AND THE ONLY SECTION THAT WAS FACING A NEIGHBOR'S

[00:05:04]

YARD. AND YET THEY ELECTED TO DO CHAIN LINK, AS OPPOSED TO KEEPING THE WROUGHT IRON LINK, SOMETHING THAT WON'T ALLOW THE GREEN GIANTS TO GROW THROUGH THEM. I FELT LIKE IT WAS. I THINK IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN UPGRADED SO THAT IT WAS THE SMALLEST SECTION OF THE FENCE THAT THEY WERE DOING AS CHAIN LINK, SO IT'S NOT LIKE IT WAS SAVING THEM MONEY AND THEY WERE GETTING GRANT MONEY TO DO IT. SO I JUST FELT DIFFERENT. I FELT LIKE IT WAS A LITTLE A WEAK WAY TO BE NEIGHBOR. IT WASN'T THE ON THE SEVENTH AND I KNOW I OFFERED THAT COMMENTARY THEN I DON'T I SEE THAT THE CHAIN LINK IS STILL IN THE RESOLUTION. SO OBVIOUSLY WE DON'T HAVE CONTROL OVER IT. BUT. MR. MOLFETTA, YOUR OPINION IS ON THE RECORD AND YOU MADE IT CLEAR RECORD THAT THAT EVENING. BUT WHAT THEY'RE DOING, THEY'RE PERMITTED TO DO BY ORDINANCE AND THAT'S IT. YEAH I UNDERSTAND. YEAH. OKAY. I'M SORRY. MR. GO AHEAD. ONE MORE COMMENT, MR. LOCKWOOD. PLEASE GO AHEAD. IT'S REALLY JUST AWARENESS. I DIDN'T REMEMBER THIS DURING THE MEETING, BUT I WENT AND SAW IT, AND I THINK I SAW IT IN THE MINUTES. I'M NOT SURE THAT IT'S IN THE RESOLUTION, BUT WHAT ALSO MADE ME FEEL BETTER WAS THAT THERE WAS THIS BUTTON THAT THEY COULD PUSH THAT WOULD SEAL THE SEAL THE WINDOWS. SO THAT WAS LIKE AN EXTRA LAYER OF SECURITY. I KNOW WE SPENT A LOT OF TIME TALKING ABOUT THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE FENCE AS A DETERRENT. YEAH. WELL, THAT'S WHAT WAS IN OUR LIKE I SAID, I DIDN'T REMEMBER IT DURING THE MEETING, BUT IT WAS IN THESE NOTES THAT THEY HAVE THIS OTHER ADVANCED SECURITY MECHANISM WHERE THEY CAN PUSH A BUTTON AND THEY CAN SEAL ALL THE WINDOWS. YEAH. AS WELL AS CAMERAS AND SURVEILLANCE. I MEAN, THE ONLY THING THEY WERE BEFORE US FOR WAS THE FENCE BECAUSE THEY NEEDED A VARIANCE FOR THAT. SO YES, BUT THERE'S A LOT MORE GOING ON THERE, RIGHT? BASED OFF OF THE GRANT. OKAY. YEAH. I JUST FELT BETTER ABOUT THAT.

YEAH. FOR SURE. MY ONLY QUESTION HERE TOO, AND I GUESS THIS IS PROBABLY FOR YOU ON THE NUMBER TWO UNDER THE STIPULATIONS IS THE INSTALLATION OF ADDITIONAL TREES AND OR LANDSCAPING AS REQUIRED BY THE BOARD ENGINEER. I MEAN, I THINK THAT LANGUAGE WORKS. WHAT DO YOU THINK? YEAH. IT'S FINE. WHAT I PICTURE IS I'M GOING TO MEET THEM OUT THERE. WE'RE GOING TO GO OVER THE LOCATION OF THE FENCE. WE'RE GOING TO GO OVER ANY TREES THAT HAVE TO BE REMOVED. YOU KNOW, I'M NOT IN FAVOR OF REMOVING ADDITIONAL TREES THAT, YOU KNOW, THERE MAY BE AN ALTERNATIVE. I'M SURE THAT THEY DON'T WANT TO REMOVE ADDITIONAL TREES THAT THEY DON'T HAVE TO. IT'S AN ADDITIONAL COST FOR THEM. SO WHAT I PICTURE IS IF THERE'S AREAS THAT WHEN I MEET WITH THEM, THEY CAN SHIFT THE FENCE ONE WAY OR ANOTHER TO AVOID HAVING TO TAKE DOWN TREES. OR IF THERE'S NO ALTERNATIVE, THEN, YOU KNOW, I WOULD RECOMMEND CERTAIN REPLACEMENT TREES OR CERTAIN BUFFERING TO GO IN TO REPLACE THAT. OKAY. I THINK THE LANGUAGE IS FINE. OKAY, GOOD. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU FOR THAT. ALL RIGHT GUYS, SO AFTER THE DISCUSSION, IS THERE SOMEONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO MOVE THE RESOLUTION FOR APPROVAL? I'LL MOVE IT. OKAY. MR. SITAR, DO I HAVE A SECOND? SECOND. ALL RIGHT, MR. LOCKWOOD.

ALL RIGHT. ROLL CALL, PLEASE, MR. LOCKWOOD. YES, MR. MOLFETTA. YES. MR. SITAR. YES. MR. YES.

OKAY. RESOLUTION HAS BEEN APPROVED. ALL RIGHT. NOW, I WILL OPEN UP THE MEETING TO THE PUBLIC FOR QUESTIONS OF A GENERAL NATURE NOT RELATED TO ANY OF THE APPLICATIONS THAT ARE ON THE AGENDA. OKAY. LET THE RECORD SHOW THERE ARE NONE. AND NOW WE WILL MOVE TO OUR

[VI.PUBLIC HEARINGS]

FIRST PUBLIC HEARING. DOCKET NUMBER 261625, SARAH GENTILE. ALL RIGHT. WELCOME, SARAH. HOW ARE YOU DOING? GOOD. HOW ARE YOU? ALL RIGHT, COME ON UP. HAVE A SEAT, PLEASE. YEP.

REMAIN STANDING, IF YOU WOULDN'T MIND. ARE YOU BOTH GOING TO TESTIFY? IS THAT OKAY? YES. PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. DO SOLEMNLY SWEAR OR AFFIRM THE TESTIMONY YOU GIVE IN THIS MATTER WILL BE THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH, AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH. YES. TO EACH STATE YOUR FULL NAME AND SPELL YOUR LAST NAME FOR THE RECORD. SARAH GENTILE, GENTILE.

THANK YOU, ROBERTO GENTILE. THANK YOU, MR. GENTILE. ALL RIGHT. HAVE A SEAT, PLEASE. AND SO, MR. AND MRS. GENTILE, THE WAY THIS WORKS IS WE'LL ASK YOU TO JUST GIVE A LITTLE TESTIMONY ABOUT WHAT YOU WANT TO DO WITH YOUR PROJECT. HOW COME? WHY TALK US THROUGH A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE PROJECT ITSELF? WHAT WOULD BE THERE IF IT WERE APPROVED, THINGS LIKE THAT. AND THEN I'LL OPEN IT UP AND ALL THE BOARD MEMBERS WILL BE ABLE TO ASK QUESTIONS OF YOU. AFTER THAT, THE EXPERTS WILL. IN THIS CASE, IT'LL. MIKE KELLY, OUR TOWN ENGINEER, AND POTENTIALLY MR. CONTI, THE ZONING BOARD ATTORNEY. AND THEN I'LL OPEN IT TO THE PUBLIC. THERE BEING NOBODY HERE FROM THE PUBLIC, I DON'T ANTICIPATE ANY QUESTIONS AFTER THAT. YOU CAN KIND OF MAYBE GIVE A CLOSING OR A LAST APPEAL, AND THEN WE WILL DISCUSS AS A BOARD THE APPLICATION IN FRONT OF YOU, AND THEN WE'LL VOTE ON IT, ASSUMING WE GET THROUGH IT TONIGHT, WHICH I THINK WE WILL, BECAUSE YOU'RE THE ONLY APPLICATION, BUT THAT'S KIND OF THE FLOW. OKAY, COOL. ALL RIGHT. SO WITH THAT, YEAH, IF YOU GUYS COULD JUST WHEN YOU'RE GOING TO

[00:10:03]

SPEAK, PUSH THE MIC CLOSE TO YOU BECAUSE IT DOESN'T PICK UP THE SAMPLE. THANK YOU. GREAT.

SO YEAH, WHY DON'T YOU TELL US A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE PROJECT AND WHY YOU'RE HERE. GREAT.

THANK YOU. YEAH, WE IT'S A RELATIVELY SIMPLE PROJECT. WE WOULD LIKE TO PROPOSE A SMALL COVERED PORTICO OVER OUR EXISTING CONCRETE LANDING. OUR HOUSE SITS FAIRLY CLOSE TO THE SETBACK LIMIT, WHICH IS WHY WE ARE PROPOSING THE C VARIANCE, BECAUSE WE ENCROACH ABOUT 2.78FT. AND THEN WE KNOW THAT THERE'S ALSO AN ADDITIONAL TWO FEET ALLOWANCE FOR. SORRY, I DON'T REMEMBER EXACTLY. IS IT CALLED. NO, NOT. COVERINGS AND THINGS LIKE THAT. YOU'RE ALLOWED TWO FEET. IT'S ON ONE OF THE ORDINANCES IN THE BACK OF THE COVERED COVERED LANDINGS ARE PERMITTED TO ENCROACH TWO FEET. YEAH. YEAH. SO THE VARIANCE IS ASKING FOR THE 0.78FT FOR IT. THE PORTICO WOULD BE ABOUT FOUR FEET BY EIGHT FEET, WHICH IS THE EXACT DIMENSIONS OF OUR EXISTING LANDING AS IT IS. AND WE WOULD REALLY LIKE IT JUST BECAUSE AS OF RIGHT NOW, OUR GUESTS, WHEN THEY COME, IF IT'S RAINING, THEY HAVE TO WAIT IN THE RAIN FOR US UNTIL WE GET THE DOOR. OUR PACKAGES ARE GETTING WET AND IT'S A LITTLE SLIPPERY, SO WE THINK THAT THE PORTICO WILL DO REALLY HELP WITH THAT. AND THEN IT'LL ALSO ESTHETICALLY ADD TO THE LOOK OF OUR HOME. GOOD. CAN YOU TALK TO US A LITTLE BIT ABOUT LIKE THE PHYSICAL STRUCTURE, WHAT IT WILL ACTUALLY LOOK LIKE, THE DESIGN OF IT? YEAH. PUT THAT ON THE RECORD FOR US PLEASE. SO IT WOULD HAVE TWO COLUMNS IN THE FRONT, ON THE FRONT SIDE OF THE LANDING. AND THEN BASICALLY IT'S JUST LIKE A COVERED ROOF OVER THE LANDING. IT WON'T ENCROACH ANY FURTHER INTO THAT. IT WON'T BE ENCLOSED. YEAH. THERE'LL BE A, THERE'LL BE A LIGHT IN IT SO THAT GUESTS AND PEOPLE WILL HAVE ILLUMINATION WHEN THEY COME UP TO OUR FRONT DOOR. AND IT WOULD BE ABOUT TEN FEET HIGH. OKAY. AND BECAUSE YOU'RE GOING TO GO INTO THE SETBACK, ALBEIT MINIMALLY, IS IT BECAUSE OF THE LOT ITSELF? ARE YOU LIKE CLOSE TO THE ROAD? IS THERE SOME LIKE, IS THE LOT MISSHAPEN IN ANY WAY? LIKE WHAT ARE SOME OF THE WHAT ARE SOME OF THE ISSUES AND CIRCUMSTANCES YOU'RE DEALING WITH ON YOUR PARTICULAR LOT? SO OURS, THE SETBACK FOR THE, OUR, OUR END ZONE IS 30FT AND OUR FRONT OF OUR HOUSE SITS LIKE 31. I DON'T KNOW, I'M SORRY, THE EXACT DIMENSION. IT'S 31 .12. YEAH. FEET BACK. SO REALLY ANY COVERING WE WANT TO PUT WOULD ENCROACH ON THE 30 FOOT. AND WHEN WE MOVED IN THERE'S ALREADY AN EXISTING LANDING THAT'S FOUR FEET OUT. SO WE'RE JUST ASKING TO COVER THE EXISTING LANDING THAT'S ALREADY THERE. OKAY. IS THE LOT ITSELF LIKE A LITTLE NARROW OR SHALLOW IN DEPTH IN SOME WAY? IT'S A LITTLE NARROW. YOU CAN YOU CAN SPEAK TO YOU GIVE HIM THE MIC.

YEAH, I WOULD AGREE. I'D SAY IT'S A LITTLE NARROW, ESPECIALLY LIKE IN LIKE THE BACK OF OUR PROPERTY. IT'S JUST NOT A LOT OF GRASS. RIGHT. OKAY. ANYTHING ELSE? IS IT LITERALLY IT'S JUST THE OVERHANG, THE POSTS. AND IS THERE OTHER STEPS? THERE WOULD BE JUST EXISTING.

YEAH. IT WOULD ALSO INCLUDE RAILINGS, BUT WE'RE JUST WAITING TO PUT THE RAILINGS BECAUSE IF WE'RE GOING TO BUILD THE PORTICO, WE'D LIKE TO BUILD IT ALL AS ONE PIECE AS OPPOSED TO PUTTING RAILINGS UP AND HAVING TO TAKE THEM DOWN TO BUILD IT. YES. OKAY. AND TO YOUR KNOWLEDGE, THE FRONT SETBACK IS THE ONLY VARIANCE YOU NEED. CORRECT. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. GOOD. MR. KELLY, DO YOU CONCUR? I DO IT'S IT'S PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD. IT'S NOT GOING TO IMPACT DRAINAGE. YOU KNOW, IT'S ALREADY AN IMPERVIOUS SURFACE. SO THEY'RE JUST COVERING, YOU KNOW, AN EXISTING IMPERVIOUS SURFACE. SO I WOULD CONSIDER THIS PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD. OKAY. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO PUT ON THE RECORD TESTIMONY WISE? NO. ALL RIGHT, ALL RIGHT. BOARD MEMBERS WITH QUESTIONS. IT'S GOING TO BE LIGHTING OVERHEAD. YEAH. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. YEAH. NOTHING ELSE. I JUST SAID LIKE A ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN QUESTION. IS IT IS IT GABLED LIKE THIS? IS THAT OKAY? ALL RIGHT. THAT

[00:15:04]

WAS ALL I WAS CURIOUS. YEAH. IT WON'T BE AN EYESORE. THAT'S WHAT HE'S GETTING AT. RIGHT. SO.

OKAY. THAT'S GOOD, MR. CHAIRMAN. I DROVE PAST THE HOUSE. I GOT ACTUALLY TO IMPROVE THE FRONT LOOK OF THE HOUSE. I YEAH, I AGREE, I AGREE WITH THE HOMEOWNERS. I ONLY HAVE ONE QUESTION AND MAYBE THIS IS FOR MIKE. THERE'S A SLIGHT INCREASE IN IMPROVED LOT COVERAGE GOING OVER AN ALREADY EXISTING IMPERVIOUS SURFACE. SO I'M TRYING TO FIGURE OUT IT'S TINY.

I DON'T KNOW IF I REALLY CARE, BUT IS IT A MATH ERROR OR IS IT AM I MISSING SOMETHING IN THE APPLICATION? YEAH. COULD I SPEAK? YEAH, OF COURSE, I ORIGINALLY HAD NO INCREASE IN LOT COVERAGE. LIKE WHEN I WENT THROUGH THE. LIKE CALCULATION TABLE. AND THEN WE GOT DENIED BECAUSE IT SAID YOU DID HAVE TO INCLUDE THE LANDING, EVEN THOUGH THE LANDING WAS ALREADY INCLUDED IN THE. OH, OKAY. SO ORIGINAL. SO OKAY, IT'S 32FT■S. GOT IT. OKAY. THANK YOU. YEAH.

AND THE, THE, THE COVERAGE, IT COUNTS TOWARDS LOT COVERAGE, LIKE BUILDING COVERAGE BECAUSE IT'S PART OF THE STRUCTURE. BUT, YOU KNOW, IN TERMS OF IMPROVED LOT COVERAGE, THAT'S REALLY GOING TO BE MINIMAL BECAUSE BOTH OF THEM CONCRETE AND THE STRUCTURE COUNT TOWARDS IMPROVED COVERAGE. SO THEY'LL BE WITHIN THEIR PERMITTED COVERAGES. OKAY. NO THANK YOU.

ANYTHING ELSE, MR. MOLFETTA? NO. MR. KELLY ANY QUESTIONS? NO. I JUST THINK TO MAKE THE RECORD CLEAR. SO THEY'RE ONE SETBACK TO THE BUILDING IS 31.13. A FOUR FEET ENCROACHMENT WOULD BE 27.13. LIKE MISS GENTILE MENTIONED, THEY'RE PERMITTED TO ENCROACH ON THAT SETBACK UP TO TWO FEET. SO THE COVERED PORCH TECHNICALLY IS TO BE SET BACK 28FT RIGHT FROM THE RIGHT OF WAY. THEY WOULD BE AT 27.13FT, RIGHT. SO THEY WOULD NEED .0.878 SEVEN FEET LESS THAN A FOOT. YEAH. .87 FEET. YEAH. LIKE THE AND THAT'S WHAT YOU HAVE IN YOUR ZONING TABLE. MIKE.

YEP. YEAH. THE EXISTING REAR SETBACK IS SHORT. SHOULD WE PUT THAT IN THE. I WOULD NOT.

THAT'S UP TO MR. CONTI. I DON'T THINK WE NEED TO NOTE THAT. BUT THAT'S UP TO HIM. IT'S NOT NECESSARY. OKAY. OKAY. EVERYONE ELSE GOOD ON QUESTIONS. OKAY. ANYONE FROM THE PUBLIC HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE GENTILES? OKAY. THERE BEING NONE. IF THERE'S ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO PUT ON THE RECORD. OTHERWISE, WE'LL MOVE INTO DISCUSSION AND VOTE. GOOD. ALL RIGHT, ALL RIGHT, GUYS, OPENED UP FOR DISCUSSION. WHO WANTS TO START? GO AHEAD, MR. KASPARIAN. BASED ON THE PHOTOS PROVIDED, I BELIEVE, AS MR. SATER SAID, I BELIEVE IT WOULD BE A BENEFIT TO THE HOME'S ARCHITECTURAL APPEARANCE TO THE STREET. SO IT WOULD ADD VALUE TO THE HOME AND THE BENEFIT OF IT. THANK YOU, MR. KASPARIAN. YEAH, I THINK I THINK IT'LL BE A GOOD IMPROVEMENT. I'M GLAD TO HEAR YOU'RE HAVING RAILINGS, BECAUSE IT SEEMED WHEN I DROVE PAST KIND OF UNSAFE LANDING. SO THAT WOULD PROBABLY BE A VERY, VERY GOOD IDEA. SO YEAH, I AGREE, MR. MOFFAT. ANYTHING TO ADD? GOOD. COMING DOWN THIS WAY. YEAH, I THINK IT ADVANCES THE MLU. L SAFETY AND CONVENIENCE. I DID VISIT THE PROPERTY. THERE ARE MANY OTHER HOMES THAT HAVE A SIMILAR SETUP, YOU KNOW, AND I THINK IT WOULD BE A GREAT IMPROVEMENT. GOOD. MR. CALZONE NO. YEAH. NO COMMENTS. YEAH, I CAN SEE IT BEING A C1 OR C2. I AGREE WITH WHAT YOU'RE SAYING, MR. LOCKWOOD. I THINK IT ALSO COULD BE A HARDSHIP IN THE FACT THAT JUST BASED OFF OF WHAT MR. SITAR WAS JUST SAYING, THE HOUSE IS PUSHED RIGHT UP AGAINST THE REAR SETBACK AND THEN BUILT RIGHT UP TO THE FRONT OF THE FRONT SETBACK. SO ANY IMPROVEMENT IS GOING TO TRIGGER A VARIANCE. SO THAT TO ME, YOU KNOW, THE LOT MIGHT BE A LITTLE BIT SMALLER THAN OTHER LOTS, YOU KNOW. SO THAT MIGHT BE A HARDSHIP. SO I THINK EITHER WAY I THINK IT WORKS.

AND I WOULD BE IN FAVOR OF APPROVING IT. SO WITH THAT, WOULD SOMEONE LIKE TO MOVE THE APPLICATION FOR APPROVAL? OKAY, MR. MOLFETTA FIRST I'LL SECOND, MR. SITAR. SECOND. OKAY. ROLL CALL. MR. YES. MR. KASPARIAN. YES. MR. LOCKWOOD. YES. MR. MOLFETTA. YES. MR. SITAR. YES.

MR. CANOVA. YES. OKAY. YOUR APPLICATION HAS BEEN APPROVED. JUST KNOW THAT YOU HAVE 45 DAYS FROM WHEN WE MEMORIALIZE IT. SO WHEN I READ, WE READ THOSE RESOLUTIONS EARLIER AND WE VOTED ON THEM TO APPROVE THEM. MR. CONTI'S GOING TO WRITE UP YOUR APPLICATION AS A

[00:20:05]

RESOLUTION. WE WILL THEN VOTE ON IT EITHER AT THE NEXT BOARD MEETING OR THE ONE AFTER THAT.

AND IT'S FROM 45 DAYS FROM THE TIME WE VOTE ON IT, ONE OF YOUR NEIGHBORS COULD APPEAL IT. SO IF YOU STARTED THE WORK NOW AND THEN THEY CAME IN TO APPEAL IT, YOU WOULD BE STARTING THE WORK AT YOUR OWN PERIL. I DON'T FORESEE THAT HAPPENING, BUT YOU SHOULD KNOW. ALL RIGHT. JUST MAKE SURE YOU PULL ALL YOUR BUILDING PERMITS AND YOU COULD GET THAT STARTED NOW AND ACTUALLY START ON IT LIKE CHAIRMAN SAID YOU'D BE WORKING ON. AND MAKE SURE YOU GET YOUR BUILDING PERMITS AND THEN YOU CAN GET STARTED. GREAT. THANK YOU SO MUCH. ALL RIGHT. GOOD LUCK WITH YOUR PROJECT. THANK YOU. YEAH. ALL RIGHT, ALL RIGHT. WAS THERE ANYTHING GUYS TO GO

[ VII. WORK SESSION]

INTO WORK SESSION FOR? ANYONE HAVE ANY DISCUSSION THAT THEY'D LIKE TO HAVE? NO. ON THIS SIDE.

I DO HAVE ONE QUESTION. OKAY. WHAT TOPIC? IT'S JUST IT'S A WE'RE VOTING ON THESE RESOLUTIONS, RIGHT? IF WE'VE GOT OKAY, LET'S LET'S DO IT. YEAH. MOTION TO MOVE INTO WORK SESSION. MR. SITAR FIRST, MR. MOLFETTA SECOND. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE, AYE. OKAY. WE ARE IN WORK SESSION. THIS WILL BE UNDER NEW BUSINESS. GO AHEAD, MR. MOLFETTA. WHEN A RESOLUTION COMES BEFORE US. I'M UNDER THE IMPRESSION THAT WE HAD VOTED ON IT PREVIOUSLY TO GET IT TO THAT POINT. RIGHT. SO IN THE AFFIRMATIVE, WE HAD VOTED TO AFFIRM THEIR APPLICATION TO APPROVE THEIR APPLICATION. AND THEN WHEN IT COMES HERE AND WE'RE ARE WE REALLY ALLOWED TO VOTE DIFFERENTLY THAN WE DID IN ORDER TO KNOW, YOU COULD ONLY WHEN WE'RE VOTING ON THE RESOLUTION, YOU'RE VOTING ON WHETHER THE RESOLUTION ACCURATELY MEMORIALIZES WHAT HAPPENED AT THE MEETING. SO IF YOU VOTED NO ON THEIR APPLICATION, THIS HAPPENS ALL THE TIME. THEN A BOARD MEMBER SAYS THEY VOTE NO. AND AND THEN MY RESPONSE IS ALWAYS, WELL, IS MY RESOLUTION WRONG? NO, YOUR RESOLUTION IS CORRECT. WELL, THEN YOU SHOULD BE VOTING YES ON THE RESOLUTION BECAUSE THE RESOLUTION SAYS WHAT THE VOTE WAS. THE RECORD SAYS, IN FACT, OUR RESOLUTION SAYS EXACTLY WHO VOTED ON WHAT. SO YOUR VOTE, IF YOU WERE A NO VOTE, THE NO VOTES ON THE BACK OF THE RESOLUTION ANYWAY. GOT IT. SO EXACTLY THE POINT OF THE QUESTION. SO THE SO. BUT IF YOU HAVE CORRECTIONS, WHICH IS WHY MICHELLE ALWAYS GETS THEM OUT A FEW DAYS BEFORE OR THE FRIDAY BEFORE. IF YOU HAVE CORRECTIONS, LET ME KNOW. LET SOMEBODY YOU KNOW, THE CHAIRMAN, THE ENGINEER, MICHELLE, LET US KNOW AND I'LL REVIEW IT. AND IT HAPPENS. SO IF WE HAVE TO CORRECT IT, WE'LL. ON THE RECORD, WE'LL SAY, YOU KNOW, WHATEVER IT IS AND WE'LL CORRECT IT, BUT WE'RE STILL VOTING YES ON THAT RESOLUTION.

JUST MAKING SURE IT ACCURATELY MEMORIALIZES WHAT HAPPENED. WONDERFUL. YEAH. ALL RIGHT.

THANK YOU. MOTION TO MOVE OUT OF WORK SESSION. OH, JUST JUST TO FOLLOW THIS. I'M GOING TO BE REPETITIVE, BUT I THINK THE THE GENERAL FEELING IN THE PAST HAS BEEN IF I VOTED NO, THEN I DON'T VOTE ON THE RESOLUTION. SO WE'VE WE'VE DONE THAT. WE'VE SKIPPED PEOPLE. SO BUT I THINK WHAT YOU'RE SAYING TONIGHT IS THEY'RE THEY'RE BIFURCATED. ONE IS INDEPENDENT OF THE OTHER.

AND THAT EVEN IF YOU VOTED NO, YOU STILL ARE EXPECTED TO VOTE ON WHETHER OR NOT THE THE MEMORIALIZE IT CORRECTLY. CORRECT. OKAY. ABSOLUTELY. WITHOUT A DOUBT. OKAY. YOU COULD SAY IT AGAIN. THE DAY WE'RE MEMORIALIZING THE RESOLUTION, I'M VOTING YES, BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT THE RESOLUTION REFLECTS IT. BUT I'M STILL AGAINST IT. I I'VE NEVER HAD THAT HAPPEN. BUT YOU COULD DO THAT. BUT STILL YOUR VOTE, YOUR VOTE IS IF YOU REALLY WANT TO MAKE IT KNOWN. WE DID THAT A LOT LAST YEAR. THAT'S WHY I SAY THE RECORD. THE RECORD. THAT'S WHY THE RECORD IS SO IMPORTANT. YOU KNOW, WE GET HUNG UP ON THE RESOLUTION SOMETIMES, BUT THE RECORD HAS TO BE CLEAR AS TO WHO DID WHAT AND WHEN. THERE WAS A REPORTED DECISION ABOUT A MONTH AGO ABOUT A BILLBOARD CASE, AND IT WENT TO THE SUPERIOR COURT, THEN WENT TO THE APPELLATE DIVISION. THE APPELLATE DIVISION SAID, WE DON'T REALLY KNOW WHY THE BOARD DID WHAT THEY DID. YOU KNOW, PROBABLY NOT A BAD IDEA TO BRING THAT CASE IN LIKE WE DID ONCE BEFORE. WE TALKED ABOUT SOME STUFF OFF THE RECORD OR OR AT LEAST IN CLOSED SESSION. AND I'LL READ WHAT THAT THAT BOARD HAD DONE. THIS BOARD DOESN'T DO THAT. THIS BOARD IS VERY CLEAR ON THEIR THEIR REASONING AND THEIR RATIONALE. PERIOD. BUT BUT ONCE IT COMES TO THE RESOLUTION, THAT'S JUST MEMORIALIZING WHAT HAPPENED. THE END. YEAH. ALL RIGHT. AND THEY ARE, IN MY OPINION, THEY'RE IMPORTANT IN THAT. THINK ABOUT HOW MANY TIMES WE GET RESOLUTIONS PULLED FROM LIKE 2001. YES. AND THAT'S WHY IT'S IMPORTANT, OBVIOUSLY, TO LOOK THROUGH THEM AND MAKE SURE THAT THEY'RE STATING WHAT YOU REMEMBER CLEARLY SO THAT WHEN

[00:25:03]

THE FUTURE BOARD NEEDS TO LOOK AT IT, THEY'RE LIKE, WHAT DID THOSE GUYS DO? OR, OH, THIS IS CLEAR. I UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY DID, YOU KNOW? YEAH, YEAH. SO. ALL RIGHT, MR. CHAIRMAN. YEAH, JUST GO AHEAD. MR. YEAH, I THINK I HEARD TWO DIFFERENT THINGS BECAUSE I KNOW MY NAME WASN'T CALLED TONIGHT ON THE HINDU TEMPLE BECAUSE I DID VOTE NO ON IT. SO I COULDN'T VOTE.

AS FAR AS THE MINUTES. IS THAT CORRECT? YOU COULDN'T VOTE ON THE RESOLUTION. RESOLUTION DIDN'T VOTE ON THE RIGHT. BUT YOU THOUGHT HE DID. NO HE DIDN'T. SHELDON NOT. DIDN'T. I WAS UNDER THE IMPRESSION THAT IF YOU WOULDN'T KNOW YOU WEREN'T VOTING, YOU COULD ABSTAIN ON THE VOTE ON THE RESOLUTION. BUT HE SHOULD VOTE ON THE RESOLUTION. SHOULD VOTE SHOULD BE CALLED. RIGHT. SO SO YEAH. WHICH SO WHAT YOU'RE SAYING IS THEN EVERYONE'S NAME GETS CALLED ON THE RESOLUTIONS, WHETHER YOU VOTED YES OR NO. THAT'S CORRECT. IF YOU WERE PRESENT. YEAH. YEAH. YEAH. AND YOU'RE VOTING YES. I VOTED NO. IT'S IN THE RESOLUTION. RIGHT.

BUT I'M JUST AFFIRMING THAT THE RESOLUTION IS ACCURATE FROM BASED ON THE MEETING. YEAH.

YOU'RE NOT SAYING YOU'RE NOT AGREEING. NO, NO. I UNDERSTAND WHAT I'M SAYING. TONIGHT. I DIDN'T GET CALLED TO VOTE ON THE RESOLUTION YOU SHOULD HAVE BECAUSE I VOTED NO. RIGHT. I WAS UNDER THE IMPRESSION THAT YOU VOTE NO. YOU DON'T. I'M GLAD I ASKED. RIGHT. SO I'M TRYING. I'M TRYING TO FIGURE OUT MR. CONTE IS ADVISING US IN THE FUTURE. EVERYONE WILL VOTE.

SO FINE. SO THEN WE KNOW THAT EVERYONE GETS A VOTE GOING FORWARD. YEAH. NO MATTER WHAT YOU NO HARM, NO FOUL. YEAH. BECAUSE YOU COULD TECHNICALLY SAY VOTE NO ON THE RESOLUTION BECAUSE IT DOESN'T REFLECT WHAT HAPPENED. THAT WOULD BE THE PURPOSE OF IT. NO OF COURSE.

YEAH. THAT WOULD BE THE PURPOSE OF IT. OTHER THAN THAT, YOU MIGHT HAVE TO BITE YOUR TONGUE, BUT YOU'RE GOING TO VOTE YES. ON MY RESOLUTION. IT GETS EVEN MORE. YOUR RESOLUTIONS ARE TO THE POINT. IT GETS EVEN MORE. AND I AND I GET I GET REVIEWED BY JERRY AND MIKE AND MICHELLE AND EVERYBODY. AND YOU KNOW WHAT? EVERYBODY DOES A GREAT JOB. IT'S THIS IS A GREAT PLACE TO WORK. EVERY TIME WE VOTE A A THING DOWN, IT GETS CONFUSING BECAUSE WHEN YOU VOTE, YOU HAVE TO VOTE YES, THAT THE RESOLUTION IS ACCURATE, THAT WE'RE TURNING IT DOWN. YOU'RE SAYING YES TO IT. AND I ALWAYS GO BACK THROUGH THAT AND SAY A YES VOTE IS, WELL, IF YOU SAY WHEN IT'S MORE, IT'S WORSE WHEN IT'S A MOTION TO DENY. YEAH, YEAH. THAT'S THAT'S THAT'S WHAT HE'S TALKING ABOUT. YEAH. THAT'S WHAT HE'S TALKING ABOUT. YEAH, YEAH YEAH. OKAY. ALL RIGHT GUYS, ANYONE ELSE GOT ANYTHING ELSE. GOOD. ALL RIGHT. MOTION TO MOVE OUT OF WORK SESSION AND ADJOURN, MR. MOLFETTA FIRST, MR. SITAR SECOND. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE.

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.